Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Text 32 · Interview · 611 words

Behavioural Economics

An interview with an economist about behavioural economics: loss aversion, present bias, nudges and the limits of the field.

Why do we pay for gym memberships we hardly use, or save less than we know we should? Behavioural economics tries to answer such questions by bringing psychology into the study of economic decisions. We spoke to Dr Rowan Ashby, who teaches the subject at a university in York, about what it has taught us and where its limits lie.

Interviewer: Let's start with the basics. What is behavioural economics reacting against? Dr Ashby: Traditional economic models often begin with a simplifying assumption: that people are rational. They know what they want, weigh up costs and benefits carefully and choose whatever serves them best. That assumption is useful, because it makes the mathematics manageable, but anyone who has ever bought something on impulse knows it isn't the whole picture.

Interviewer: So people are irrational? Dr Ashby: I'd be wary of putting it that way. It's not so much that we're irrational as that our rationality is bounded. We have limited time, limited information and limited mental energy, so we rely on rules of thumb, mental shortcuts that work well most of the time but lead us astray in predictable ways. The word 'predictable' matters. If our mistakes were random, they would cancel each other out. Because they're systematic, they can be studied.

Interviewer: Can you give an example? Dr Ashby: The best known is probably loss aversion, which the psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky studied in the 1970s. Broadly speaking, losing something feels worse than gaining the same thing feels good. Losing a ten-pound note hurts more than finding one pleases us. That helps explain why people hold on to things they would never buy at today's price, and why 'don't miss out' is such a powerful line in advertising.

Interviewer: And the gym membership? Dr Ashby: That's what we call present bias. When we sign up in January, we imagine our future selves as disciplined. When the evening actually arrives, the sofa wins. We consistently give more weight to what happens now than to what happens later, which affects everything from exercise to saving for retirement.

Interviewer: The field is often linked with 'nudges'. What are they? Dr Ashby: A nudge is a change in the way a choice is presented that makes one option easier, without forbidding anything or changing the financial rewards very much. The classic case is defaults. In the UK, for instance, most employees are now automatically enrolled in a workplace pension, though they're free to opt out. Changing the default from opting in to opting out led to a large rise in the number of people saving. Nobody was forced; the path of least resistance simply moved.

Interviewer: Not everyone is enthusiastic about nudging, though. Dr Ashby: Quite right, and the criticisms deserve to be taken seriously. Some people regard nudges as paternalistic: who decides what's good for me? Others worry that companies can use the same techniques to push us towards choices that benefit them rather than us. There's also a scientific concern. Some well-publicised findings have proved difficult to replicate, and careful reviews suggest that the average effect of many nudges is smaller than early enthusiasm implied. Nudges can help, but they are no substitute for good policy.

Interviewer: So what has the field really achieved? Dr Ashby: Its greatest contribution, I'd argue, is a more realistic picture of human beings. It hasn't replaced traditional economics; the two increasingly work together. But it has made economists more humble about their assumptions. And for ordinary people, knowing about these tendencies is genuinely useful. Once you recognise that a 'limited-time offer' is designed to trigger loss aversion, it loses a little of its power.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
assumption/əˈsʌmpʃən/something you accept as true without proof
impulse/ˈɪmpʌls/a sudden wish to do something, without planning
bounded/ˈbaʊndɪd/having limits
rules of thumb/ˌruːlz əv ˈθʌm/simple, practical ways of deciding, based on experience
lead us astray/ˌliːd əs əˈstreɪ/make us go in the wrong direction or make mistakes
systematic/ˌsɪstəˈmætɪk/following a regular pattern; not random
loss aversion/ˈlɒs əˌvɜːʃən/the tendency to feel losing something more strongly than gaining the same thing
present bias/ˌprezənt ˈbaɪəs/the tendency to care more about now than about the future
retirement/rɪˈtaɪəmənt/the time when you stop working, usually when you are older
defaults/dɪˈfɔːlts/options that happen automatically unless you choose something else
opt out/ˌɒpt ˈaʊt/choose not to take part
the path of least resistance/ðə ˌpɑːθ əv ˌliːst rɪˈzɪstəns/the easiest way, which needs the least effort
paternalistic/pəˌtɜːnəˈlɪstɪk/deciding for people what is good for them, as a parent does for a child
replicate/ˈreplɪkeɪt/repeat a study and get the same result
substitute for/ˈsʌbstɪtjuːt fɔː/something used instead of another thing
humble/ˈhʌmbl/not too proud; aware of your own limits

Behavioural Economics: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.