On a wet Tuesday morning in Hexham, the café at the back of Whitfield's Books is surprisingly busy. A reading group has taken over the big table, two students are working on laptops and a toddler is being read to in the children's corner. 'When I was a girl, this was the stockroom,' says Grace Whitfield, who took over the shop from her parents. 'Now it's the reason half our customers come in.'
Whitfield's experience reflects one of the most significant shifts in modern economic life. Over recent decades, a growing share of shopping has moved online, accelerated by faster delivery, smartphones and, more recently, the pandemic, when many people bought their groceries online for the first time. For many traditional shops, the effects have been painful. Familiar chains have closed branches or disappeared altogether, and empty units have become a common sight on some high streets.
Yet the picture is more complicated than a simple story of decline. Physical shops still account for a large part of what people buy, and a number of online retailers have, somewhat ironically, opened shops of their own. The reason, explains Dr Omar Haddad, who researches retail at a university in Manchester, is that the two channels do different things well. 'Online is unbeatable for convenience and choice,' he says. 'But you can't try on a coat or smell a candle through a screen, and a website can't give advice the way a knowledgeable person can. The most successful businesses now combine both.' Analysts call this approach 'omnichannel': a customer might browse online, collect in store and return an item by post.
If shops are no longer simply places to pick up goods, what are they for? Increasingly, the answer seems to be experience. Bookshops host author events, outdoor shops offer climbing walls and cookware shops run cooking classes. Some retailers now think of their stores less as places of sale than as showrooms, where customers discover products they may eventually buy online. Measuring the value of a shop, in other words, is no longer as simple as counting what passes through the till.
Town centres are adapting too. Where large stores have closed, some councils and community groups have converted the buildings into flats, health centres, libraries or spaces for small businesses. Pop-up shops, which rent a space for weeks rather than years, allow new businesses to test an idea without a long-term commitment. Markets and independent shops, which can offer something distinctive, have in some places proved more resilient than expected.
None of this means that the future is settled. Online shopping raises questions of its own. Fast delivery depends on large warehouses and many vans, and frequent returns create extra journeys and packaging. Researchers disagree about whether shopping online is, overall, better or worse for the environment than driving to the shops; much depends on how far people travel and how deliveries are organised. There are also concerns about working conditions in some parts of the delivery industry, and about people, often older, who are less comfortable shopping online.
Technology will continue to reshape the way we buy things, from cashless payments to personalised recommendations. Grace Whitfield, however, is cautiously optimistic. 'People will always want somewhere to go,' she says, pouring another coffee. 'A shop can't just sell things any more. It has to give people a reason to leave the house.' If she is right, the high street of the future may look less like a row of stores and more like a hub for the community.