This roundtable was recorded for Classroom Today, a magazine for teachers and parents. The host, Natalie Brooks, asks four guests whether secondary schools in Britain should move to a four-day week.
Natalie: Owen Lloyd, you're a head teacher in Shrewsbury, and you've spent a year studying schools abroad that teach pupils on only four days. What drew you to the idea? Owen: Mainly the teachers. Recruitment is the biggest problem I face. Every year I advertise for science teachers, and every year I get a handful of applications. In the American districts I visited, the four-day week was one of the few things that made people want to work there. But let me be clear: I'm not proposing that pupils simply stay at home on Fridays. My version would have four longer days of lessons and an optional fifth day of clubs, sport and catch-up sessions, run partly by outside organisations. Natalie: Dr Helen Achebe, you've reviewed the research. What does it show? Helen: Less than either side would like, frankly. Most of the studies come from rural parts of the United States, where schools often adopted the shorter week to save money on transport and heating, so we should be careful about applying the findings to a city school in Britain. Where effects on attainment have been measured, they tend to be small, and in several studies slightly negative, particularly for younger children. There's also some evidence that teachers are happier. So it isn't a disaster, but nor is it the miracle that some headlines suggest. Owen: I'd accept that, though I'd point out that those schools usually just removed a day. Hardly anyone has tested a model with a structured fifth day. Helen: Which is exactly why I'd want it piloted carefully before anyone talks about rolling it out across the country.
Natalie: Sophie Marsh, as a parent, how does this sound to you? Sophie: Honestly, my first reaction was panic. I'm a nurse, I work twelve-hour shifts, often on Fridays. If school finishes on Thursday, who looks after my eleven-year-old? Owen's optional day helps, but the word 'optional' worries me. The families who most need that day are the ones least likely to take it up, or least able to get their children there. And for some children, school is where they get their only hot meal of the day. Owen: That's a concern I share, which is why the fifth day would include lunch and be free for every family. Sophie: Then it's really a five-day week with a different timetable, isn't it? I'm not against that, but let's call it what it is.
Natalie: Kieran Doyle, you're in the sixth form. What do students think? Kieran: Opinion's divided, to be honest. Lots of my friends love the idea of a day for independent study, and I'd use it for revision and for my part-time job. But I know people who'd just sleep until lunchtime. And longer days have a cost too. By the last lesson of a seven-hour day, nobody is learning anything about quadratic equations. Helen: Kieran's point about fatigue is well supported, actually. Concentration drops towards the end of the day, especially for younger pupils, so you can't assume that adding forty minutes to each day replaces a whole day of learning.
Natalie: So where does that leave us? Should schools make the change? Helen: Not yet. A few carefully evaluated trials, with the results made public, would tell us far more than any amount of argument. Sophie: As long as working parents are part of the planning from the start, not an afterthought. Kieran: And students. We're the ones who'd be sitting in that last lesson. Owen: I'd happily volunteer my school for a trial. If it doesn't work, I'll be the first to say so.