Isla Fraser grew up on the edge of the Cairngorms and has spent twenty years filming animals in the wild, from otters in Shetland to snow leopards in the mountains of Central Asia. Her latest series, Small Lives, follows the animals that live in British hedges and fields. She spoke to Tom Ashworth for Wild Isles Magazine.
Tom: Your new series is about hedgehogs, voles and beetles rather than lions or whales. Why go small? Isla: Partly because those animals are on our doorstep and most people have never really looked at them. A hedgerow is a whole city if you get down to its level. But it's also a practical choice. To film a dormouse waking from hibernation, I don't need to fly anywhere, which matters to me more each year. Tom: How long does a sequence like that take? Isla: The dormouse took eleven weeks for about four minutes of television. People are often shocked by that ratio, but patience is really the whole job. Most days nothing happens, and you have to be content with that.
Tom: Let's turn to something critics often raise. Viewers sometimes discover that a scene they assumed was continuous was actually filmed over several days, or that a 'wild' moment was shot in a controlled setting. Is that dishonest? Isla: It depends on what you're claiming. I think combining footage from different days to tell one true story is legitimate, as long as the behaviour is real. Every film is edited; that's what makes it watchable. Where I draw the line is staging: putting an animal in a situation it would never be in, or provoking behaviour for the camera. And if we film in a controlled setting, say a nest box with a camera inside, I believe we should tell the audience, not bury it on a website nobody visits. Tom: Some of your colleagues would say that kind of transparency spoils the magic. Isla: I've heard that argument, and I understand it, but I think it underestimates viewers. People are fascinated by how we get the shots. Being honest about our methods hasn't reduced our audience; if anything, the 'making of' sections are among the most popular parts of the series.
Tom: What about the stories themselves? Critics argue that wildlife films give animals human personalities, a brave mother, a villain, a happy ending, and that this distorts science. Isla: That one I'm genuinely torn about. I dislike narration that tells you a fox is 'wicked' or a vole is 'heartbroken'. We don't know that, and it gives children the wrong idea. On the other hand, emotion is what makes people care, and caring is what makes them protect a habitat. A purely scientific film might be more accurate and watched by almost nobody. So I try to find a middle path: tell a story, but let the animals' real behaviour carry it. Tom: And technology? Drones and tiny cameras have transformed the industry. Isla: They have, mostly for the better. We can now see behaviour that was simply invisible twenty years ago. But I'm wary of drones near nesting birds. A drone can cause real distress, and some filmmakers fly them far too close. The rule on my team is simple: if an animal changes its behaviour because of us, we back off, however good the shot.
Tom: Has that ever cost you a sequence? Isla: Many times. I once spent three weeks waiting for a pair of ospreys, and I abandoned the shot on the final morning because the female kept leaving the nest. It was gutting at the time, but I've never regretted it. Tom: Finally, what advice would you give a teenager who wants to do your job? Isla: Start with your phone and your local park. Learn the animals before you learn the cameras. And keep a notebook: the best filmmakers I know are, above all, good naturalists.