This debate took place at a festival of ideas in Sheffield. The chair, Grace Okonkwo, asks three speakers whether exams should be abolished.
Grace: Leah Bradshaw, you're arguing that most exams should go. Why? Leah: Because I've taught English for fifteen years and I've watched exams narrow what happens in my classroom. When everything depends on a two-hour paper in June, we end up teaching pupils how to answer the question rather than how to think about a novel. I'm not saying we should abolish every exam tomorrow. I'm saying that a two-hour snapshot shouldn't decide a young person's future, and that most of what we value, such as research, discussion, drafting and redrafting, can be assessed far better through coursework and portfolios. Grace: Professor Martin Hale, you disagree. Martin: Strongly, I'm afraid, although I share some of Leah's frustrations. My objection is about fairness. An exam is one of the few situations in which every candidate sits the same paper, at the same time, under the same conditions, marked by someone who doesn't know their name. Coursework sounds kinder, but it favours pupils with a quiet bedroom, educated parents and, these days, access to tools that can write the essay for them. When coursework was used more widely in the past, worries about authenticity were one of the main reasons it was reduced. Leah: But exams favour particular pupils too: the ones who stay calm under pressure and have good memories. That's not a level playing field either. Martin: No assessment is perfect. The question is which flaws are easier to manage. I'd rather have a system where a nervous pupil can practise and improve than one where a wealthy pupil can buy help.
Grace: Ayesha Rahman, you'll be sitting your GCSEs next summer. What's your view? Ayesha: I'm somewhere in the middle, which probably sounds like sitting on the fence, but it's honestly how I feel. The stress is real. I know people who've stopped sleeping properly, and I've had days when I couldn't face my revision timetable. So when Leah talks about snapshots, I completely get it. But I also like knowing exactly what I'm working towards. Coursework never really ends: you can always add another paragraph, and that pressure lasts all year rather than for a few weeks. Grace: So what would you change? Ayesha: Fewer exams, not none. We sit something like thirty papers in a few weeks. If some subjects, like art or drama, were assessed mainly through projects, and the rest had fewer, shorter papers, I think most of us would be less frazzled and still have a clear goal.
Martin: I could live with fewer papers. My concern is with abolition, not reduction. Thirty papers is arguably more than anyone needs to show what they know. Leah: That's a bigger concession than I expected, Martin, and I'll take it. In return, I'll admit that I'd keep exams where they genuinely measure something, mental arithmetic, say, or translating a passage. Grace: Then is this debate really about abolition at all? Martin: Not as far as I'm concerned. Abolition makes a good headline, but the real choices are about balance and safeguards. Leah: I'd still go further than Martin. I'd want universities and employers to look at a much wider record of what a young person can do, not just a set of grades. Ayesha: And I'd want whoever decides to ask people my age. We're the ones on the receiving end.