Curious Minds is a weekly science podcast. In this episode, the presenter, Ben Carlisle, talks to the cognitive psychologist Dr Nadia Fernandes and the composer and jazz pianist Callum Reid about where new ideas come from.
Ben: Nadia, let's start with a myth. Is it true that creative people mainly use the right side of the brain? Nadia: It's a lovely story, but no. Brain-imaging studies suggest that creative thinking draws on networks spread across both hemispheres. Roughly speaking, one network lets the mind wander and come up with possibilities, and another helps us judge them and decide which are worth keeping. What seems to matter is how well those systems cooperate, not which side of your head is doing the work. Ben: Callum, does that match your experience of writing music? Callum: The wandering and the judging, yes, absolutely. But I'm always slightly sceptical when science claims to explain art. Knowing which part of my brain lights up when I write a melody doesn't tell you why one melody moves people to tears and another is forgotten. Nadia: That's fair. We study the process, not the value of the result. I'd never claim that a brain scan can tell you whether a song is any good.
Ben: Another popular idea is the lone genius, suddenly struck by inspiration in the bath. How much truth is there in that? Nadia: Very little, I'm afraid. When researchers look closely at so-called breakthroughs, they usually find years of preparation and plenty of conversations with other people. Creativity is mostly the recombination of things you already know, in a way nobody has tried before. That's why broad interests help: the more varied your raw material, the more combinations are available. Callum: I'd go further. Inspiration is overrated. I compose for two hours every morning, whether I feel like it or not. Most of what I write is mediocre, and I throw it away. But I've learned that good ideas only arrive if I'm already working when they come. Ben: That sounds rather unromantic. Callum: Perhaps, but it's freeing. If you wait for inspiration, you might wait for ever.
Ben: Nadia, is there anything in the bath idea, though? People do say ideas come to them in the shower or on a walk. Nadia: There is something, yes. Psychologists call it incubation. If you've worked hard on a problem and then step away to do something undemanding, some studies find that people come back with better solutions. The evidence isn't completely consistent, but the effect seems strongest when the break follows a period of real effort. So the shower helps, but only if you've done the thinking first. Callum: Which is exactly my point. The walk works because of the two hours that came before it.
Ben: Can creativity be taught, or are some people simply born with it? Nadia: Differences between individuals are real, but the evidence suggests that creative skills respond well to practice, especially producing lots of ideas before judging any of them. One thing that reliably gets in the way is fear of failure. In classrooms where mistakes are treated as normal, children tend to take more creative risks. Callum: I teach young musicians, and I see that all the time. The most talented students are sometimes the most cautious, because they've got a reputation to protect. In the first lesson, I make them play deliberately wrong notes, just to break the spell. Ben: Finally, one piece of advice for listeners who want to be more creative. Nadia: Collect widely. Read, listen and talk to people outside your own field. Callum: And turn up. Every day, even when nothing comes. Especially then.