This is an edited transcript from The Open Question, a weekly debate programme. The presenter, Daniel Hughes, is joined by three guests to discuss whether popular towns should charge visitors a small tax for every night they stay.
Daniel: Let's start with the basic idea. Morwenna Trevithick, you're a councillor in a Cornish seaside town, and your council is considering a levy of £2 per person per night. Why? Morwenna: Because our town of eleven thousand people welcomes nearly a million visitors a year, and the strain shows. Our bins overflow in August, our public toilets need cleaning four times a day, and our lifeguards are funded from a budget that has barely grown in a decade. Residents pay for all of that through their council tax. A modest charge simply asks the people who enjoy the place to chip in. Two pounds is less than the price of an ice cream. Daniel: Rhys Pritchard, you run a family guesthouse. Is it really that simple? Rhys: With respect, nothing is ever as simple as the price of an ice cream. A family of four staying for a week would pay fifty-six pounds on top of everything else, and families are already squeezed. My margins are thin. If a family decides that the next valley, which has no levy, is better value, it's me who loses the booking, not the council. And it's people like me who would have to collect the money, fill in the forms and explain it to guests at the desk.
Daniel: Dr Amara Osei, you study the economics of tourism. Do these taxes drive visitors away? Amara: The honest answer is that it depends on the design, but the research I'm familiar with suggests that small, flat charges have only a marginal effect on demand. Visitors tend to choose a destination for its beaches, its history or its food, and a pound or two a night rarely tips the balance. That said, I'd be cautious about generalising. A busy city with no real alternative is very different from a rural area where the next village is ten minutes away. Rhys's concern isn't unreasonable. Morwenna: But surely the alternative is worse. If we don't raise money, services decline, and then visitors stop coming anyway. Rhys: I don't dispute that the toilets need cleaning. What I dispute is the idea that visitors are the only problem. Tourism pays my wages, my cleaner's wages and the wages of the café owner down the road. It's not as though we contribute nothing already.
Amara: That's a fair point, and it's one reason why I think the debate is often framed badly. The question isn't really whether tourists should pay, because they already do, through VAT and through the businesses they use. The question is whether a dedicated charge, collected locally and spent locally, is a fairer way of matching costs with the people who create them. Daniel: And is it? Amara: Potentially, yes, but only if two conditions are met. First, the money must be ring-fenced, so that it can't quietly disappear into the general budget. Second, the council must publish exactly how it's spent. Where levies have lost public support, it's usually been because nobody could see what they paid for. Morwenna: I'd accept both of those conditions without hesitation. In fact, our proposal includes an annual report and a panel of residents and business owners who would decide on priorities.
Rhys: Well, that's the first I've heard of a business panel, and I'd welcome it. If I could tell guests, 'Your two pounds paid for the new footpath down to the cove,' I'd find the charge a great deal easier to defend. What I won't support is a charge that simply plugs a gap that the government ought to fill. Daniel: So, is there any common ground here? Amara: More than you might think. Nobody on this panel is arguing that tourism is bad, and nobody is claiming that public services pay for themselves. The real disagreement is about trust: whether the money will do what it says it will. Rhys: I'd go along with that. Show me the footpath and I'll stop grumbling. Morwenna: I'll hold you to that, Rhys.