Few acts seem as straightforwardly good as giving to charity. Whether it is a coin dropped into a collecting tin outside a supermarket in Chester or a monthly direct debit to an international aid agency, donating is widely regarded as a moral duty, or at least a mark of decency. Yet in recent decades a quieter, more uncomfortable question has gained ground among economists, philosophers and charity workers themselves: does the money actually achieve what donors hope it will?
The question is not as cynical as it may sound. Charities differ enormously in how effectively they turn donations into results. Two organisations working on the same problem can produce very different outcomes, and some well-intentioned projects have, on closer inspection, made little lasting difference. Researchers who run careful trials, comparing communities that receive a programme with similar ones that do not, have found that some popular approaches work far less well than expected, while some unglamorous ones, such as providing simple health treatments, deliver remarkable benefits at low cost.
This kind of evidence lies at the heart of a movement often called effective altruism, which urges donors to give where each pound will do the most good. Its supporters argue that, since resources are limited, choosing a charity on the basis of a moving advert or a personal connection is, in effect, choosing to help fewer people. 'Feeling good and doing good are not the same thing,' says Dr Eleanor Marsh, who teaches ethics at a university in Bristol. 'If we care about outcomes, we ought to look at the evidence, just as we would before buying a car.'
Not everyone is persuaded. Critics point out that many valuable things are hard to measure. How do you put a number on the comfort a hospice brings to a family, the confidence a youth club gives a shy teenager, or the long, slow work of campaigning to change a law? An approach that rewards only what can be counted, they warn, may push money towards short-term, measurable projects and away from patient work whose benefits appear over decades. Others object that giving is also an expression of identity and belonging: supporting the lifeboat service in a coastal town, or the local food bank, is part of what it means to be a member of a community.
A further debate concerns overheads, the money spent on salaries, offices and fundraising rather than directly on a cause. Many donors assume that the lower a charity's overheads, the better it must be. Experts increasingly regard this as misleading. A charity that refuses to invest in skilled staff, good accounting or proper evaluation may be cheap to run but poor at its job. 'Asking only how much goes on administration is like judging a hospital by the size of its car park,' says Samuel Okafor, who has advised several small charities in Manchester. 'The real question is what the organisation achieves.'
There is also the question of power. Large international donors have sometimes been criticised for deciding, from far away, what communities need, rather than listening to the people they intend to help. In response, a growing number of organisations hand more control to local groups, or even give money directly to families and trust them to spend it wisely. Early research on such cash transfers has often been encouraging, though results vary from place to place.
So does charity work? The honest answer is that some of it works brilliantly, some works modestly and some barely works at all, and that the difference is not always visible from the outside. Far from being a reason to stop giving, this suggests that donors might give more thoughtfully: asking what a charity is trying to achieve, how it knows whether it is succeeding, and whether the people it serves have a voice. Generosity, it seems, is most powerful when it is combined with curiosity.