The idea that people should rise according to their talent and effort, rather than their family, wealth or connections, is one of the most widely shared ideals of modern societies. Yet the word 'meritocracy' itself was coined as a warning. The British sociologist Michael Young introduced it in his 1958 book The Rise of the Meritocracy, a satire imagining a future in which those judged clever enough ruled over everyone else, and in which those left behind had nobody to blame but themselves. On this week's edition of Open Question, presenter Clare Whitfield asks two guests whether the ideal still deserves our faith: Professor Daniel Ashworth, an economist, and Dr Nadia Rahman, a philosopher who writes about fairness.
Clare: Daniel, let's start with the case for meritocracy. Daniel: Gladly. Think of the alternative. For most of history, your future was decided largely at birth. Jobs in government, the law or the army often went to people with the right surname. Opening those positions to open competition, through exams, interviews and qualifications, was a huge step forward, both for fairness and for efficiency. If I need an operation, I want the surgeon who is best at surgery, not the one whose uncle runs the hospital. Clare: Nadia, surely that's hard to argue with?
Nadia: I don't disagree with any of it, as far as it goes. Choosing the best-qualified surgeon is obviously right. My concern is what happens when meritocracy becomes not just a way of filling jobs but a whole story about who deserves what. Talent and effort are never measured on a level playing field. A child who grows up with books at home, a quiet place to study and parents who can pay for extra lessons arrives at every exam with advantages they did nothing to earn. When we then call the results 'merit', we risk turning privilege into something that looks like virtue.
Daniel: That's a fair point about opportunity, but it's an argument for making meritocracy work better, not for abandoning it. Invest in early education, support families, widen access to university, and competition becomes fairer. Nadia: I'd welcome all of that. But even in a perfectly fair contest, some people would still lose, and I worry about the message they receive. If success is entirely deserved, then failure must be deserved too. Studies suggest that people who believe they live in a meritocracy can become less sympathetic towards those who struggle. And the winners may grow complacent, assuming that their position reflects nothing but their own hard work.
Clare: Is there a middle way? Daniel: I think so. We can keep rewarding skill while being more modest about what it proves. Luck plays a bigger part in most careers than successful people like to admit: the right teacher, the right moment, good health. Nadia: Yes, and we might also value a wider range of contributions. A society that admires only a narrow kind of academic achievement tends to overlook the care workers, electricians and farmers it depends on. Dignity shouldn't be a prize handed out to exam winners. Daniel: On that, I suspect we agree more than our listeners expected.
Clare: Michael Young himself later expressed dismay that a word he had meant as a warning was being used as a compliment. Perhaps the lesson is that merit is a useful tool for choosing who does a job, but a poor yardstick for a person's worth. Daniel, Nadia, thank you both.