Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Text 25 · Feature · 623 words

The Right to Repair

A visit to a local repair café opens a wider look at the right-to-repair movement, its environmental case and the concerns of manufacturers.

On the first Saturday of every month, a church hall in Stroud fills with broken things: toasters that no longer toast, lamps that flicker, a child's remote-controlled car with a wheel missing. This is the town's repair café, one of thousands that have sprung up around the world since the first opened in Amsterdam in 2009. Volunteers with screwdrivers and soldering irons help visitors to fix their possessions for free and, ideally, teach them how to do it themselves.

On a recent visit, I watched Tom Ashworth, a retired electrician, examine a vacuum cleaner brought in by a teenager called Lily. Tom: Right, let's have a look. When did it stop working? Lily: Last week. Mum said we should just buy a new one, but it seemed such a waste. Tom: Quite often it's something small. Ah – see this? The belt has snapped. It's a cheap part, if you can get hold of one. Lily: Is that usually the hard bit? Tom: More and more, yes. Some machines are glued together so you can't open them without breaking them, and some companies won't sell spare parts at all.

Tom's frustration lies at the heart of the right to repair movement, which argues that people who buy a product should be able to fix it, or have it fixed by an independent repairer, at a reasonable cost. Campaigners point to designs that make repair unnecessarily difficult: batteries that cannot be removed, unusual screws that require special tools, and software that stops a device working if a part is replaced by anyone other than the manufacturer. Some also accuse companies of planned obsolescence – deliberately designing products to have a limited life so that customers must replace them sooner – although this is difficult to prove and manufacturers firmly deny it.

The environmental case is powerful. Electronic waste is one of the fastest-growing types of rubbish in the world, and making new devices consumes energy and valuable raw materials. Extending the life of a phone or washing machine by even a few years can significantly reduce its overall environmental footprint. There is an economic argument too: repair creates local, skilled jobs and saves households money.

Manufacturers, however, have their own concerns, and not all of them are self-serving. They argue that sealed designs can make devices thinner, lighter and more resistant to water and dust. Poor-quality repairs, they warn, could create safety risks, particularly with batteries, while giving outsiders access to software might threaten security. Some also worry about protecting their intellectual property. 'Nobody is against repair,' says Rachel Dunmore, who works for an industry association. 'But quality and safety must come first, and that means trained technicians and genuine parts.'

Lawmakers have begun to respond. In recent years, the European Union and the UK have introduced rules requiring manufacturers of certain household appliances, such as washing machines and fridges, to make spare parts available for a number of years. Some companies, partly in response to public pressure, now sell repair kits and publish repair manuals online. Campaigners welcome these steps but argue that there is still a long way to go, and that repair should be not merely possible but genuinely affordable.

Back in Stroud, twenty minutes later, the vacuum cleaner is humming again. Tom found a matching belt in the café's box of spare parts, and Lily fitted it herself under his supervision. Lily: I honestly thought it was finished. Now I actually know how it works inside. Tom: That's the point. Every time someone mends something, they're a bit less likely to throw the next thing away. It is a small victory, but for a movement built on the belief that things should be made to last, small victories add up.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
flicker/ˈflɪkə/to shine in an unsteady way, getting brighter and darker quickly
repair café/rɪˈpeə ˌkæfeɪ/a free event where volunteers help people to fix broken things
sprung up/ˌsprʌŋ ˈʌp/appeared suddenly, often in large numbers
soldering irons/ˈsəʊldərɪŋ ˌaɪənz/hot tools used to join small metal parts together, for example in electrical equipment
spare parts/ˌspeə ˈpɑːts/new pieces that you can use to replace broken ones in a machine
right to repair/ˌraɪt tə rɪˈpeə/the idea that people should be able to fix the things they own
planned obsolescence/ˌplænd ˌɒbsəˈlesəns/making products so that they stop working or go out of date quickly on purpose
electronic waste/ˌelekˌtrɒnɪk ˈweɪst/old or broken phones, computers and other electrical things that are thrown away
raw materials/ˌrɔː məˈtɪəriəlz/natural substances, such as metals, that are used to make products
footprint/ˈfʊtprɪnt/the effect that something has on the environment
self-serving/ˌself ˈsɜːvɪŋ/done mainly to help yourself, not others
sealed/siːld/closed completely so that it cannot easily be opened
intellectual property/ˌɪntəlˌektʃuəl ˈprɒpəti/ideas, designs and inventions that legally belong to a person or company
manuals/ˈmænjuəlz/books or guides that explain how to use or fix something
supervision/ˌsuːpəˈvɪʒən/watching someone to make sure they do something correctly and safely

The Right to Repair: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.