Every week on Big Questions, our school radio programme, two guests discuss a topic on which people disagree. This week, presenter Amira Hassan talked to Grace Mensah, a museum curator from Leeds, and James Whitfield, a historian, about whether museums should return objects to the countries they originally came from.
Amira: Grace, let's start with the basics. Why is this question being asked at all? Grace: Many large museums in Europe hold objects that came from other parts of the world, often during the colonial period, when powerful European countries ruled other lands. Some objects were bought fairly, but others were taken by force or without consent. Many communities see them as an important part of their heritage, and they would like them back. Amira: James, you're more cautious, aren't you? James: I am. I don't think there's a simple answer that works for every object. Some were bought or given legally, and big museums like the British Museum allow millions of visitors from all over the world to see them for free. There's real value in showing different cultures side by side in one place.
Grace: That's true, but it's easy to say that from London. If you live in the country an object came from, you might never be able to travel thousands of miles to see a part of your own history. James: I agree that matters. My worry is more practical. Some objects are very fragile, and moving them carries a risk. We also need to be sure that they'll be looked after properly. Grace: With respect, many of those countries now have excellent modern museums. And in recent years, several European museums have already returned objects, and the results have been very positive.
Amira: So is there any common ground between you? James: I think so. I'd support returns wherever there's clear evidence that something was looted. In other cases, long-term loans, shared exhibitions and digital copies could be a good compromise. Grace: I'd agree with that as a starting point. What matters most to me is that museums are honest about where their objects came from. Every label should tell the full story, even when that story is uncomfortable. Amira: Thank you both. Listeners, what do you think? Send us your views – and remember, you can disagree respectfully.