Not so long ago, many people believed that the vinyl record was finished. When CDs arrived in the 1980s, and later when music moved online, record players were put away in lofts and old albums ended up in charity shops. Today, however, vinyl is enjoying a remarkable comeback. Sales in the UK have risen for many years in a row, and record shops that once struggled to stay afloat now have queues outside on busy Saturdays.
So what is behind this revival? For many fans, it is all about the experience. 'Streaming is brilliant for discovering new music, but it's very easy to skip a song after ten seconds,' says Martin Oakes, who has run a record shop in Norwich for twenty-two years. 'With a record, you take it out of the sleeve, put it on and sit down. You listen to an album from start to finish, the way the band intended.' Many listeners also love the large artwork on the cover, which they can hold in their hands and study while the music plays.
Surprisingly, a large number of buyers are young. Isla Brennan, sixteen, started collecting records two years ago, when her grandad gave her his old record player. 'My friends thought it was a bit old-fashioned at first,' she admits. 'Now three of them have got their own. We go browsing in second-hand shops together at the weekend, and finding a rare album for a couple of pounds is a real thrill.' Some people even buy records by their favourite artists without owning a record player at all, simply to put them on the wall or to support the musicians.
Not everyone is convinced, though. Critics point out that new records are expensive, often costing between £25 and £35, while a monthly streaming subscription costs much less and offers millions of songs. Records also take up a lot of space, they can easily be scratched, and they are made of plastic, which raises questions about their environmental impact. Some sound engineers argue that the claim that vinyl 'sounds better' is largely a matter of taste: digital files can be technically more accurate, even if many listeners prefer the 'warmer' sound of a record.
Most experts agree that vinyl will not replace streaming. The great majority of music is still listened to online, and that is unlikely to change. Instead, the two formats seem to complement each other. As Martin puts it, 'People find a band on their phone, fall in love with them, and then come here to buy the album on vinyl. It's not one or the other. For a lot of my customers, owning a record is a way of saying: this music really matters to me.'