Early one morning last month, residents of a quiet street in Ipswich woke up to find a huge painting of a heron on the side of an old warehouse. Nobody saw who painted it, and nobody has owned up to it. Within days, people were arguing about it online: some want the painting protected, while others think it should be painted over. We asked two readers to share their views.
'Street art makes a town feel alive' – Leo Clarke, 19, art student I walk past that warehouse every day, and for years it was a grey, neglected wall that nobody looked at twice. Now people stop, take photos and talk to each other. That's what good art does. Many cities, including Bristol, welcome visitors who come especially to see their murals, and local cafés and shops benefit too. Street art is also free and open to everyone. Galleries can feel intimidating if you've never been to one, but a painting on a wall doesn't ask you to buy a ticket or dress in a certain way. Of course, I'm not defending people who spray their names on someone's front door – that's simply damage. But I think towns should offer more legal walls, where artists can practise without breaking the law.
'Permission matters' – Margaret Hughes, 58, shop owner I'll be honest: I think the heron is rather lovely. But that isn't really the point. The artist painted on a building that belongs to someone else without asking, and that is vandalism, however talented the painter is. Two years ago, the shutter on my shop was covered in tags overnight, and it cost me £400 to have them removed. Nobody asked whether I liked them. My worry is that if we praise the heron, we send a message that it's acceptable to paint wherever you like, as long as the result is pretty. And who decides what is pretty? One person's masterpiece is another person's eyesore. I'm all for street art when it is commissioned – when the owner of the wall agrees and the local community has a say.
So, is there any common ground? Interestingly, both of our writers support legal walls and murals that are painted with permission. The owner of the warehouse has now said that she would like the heron to stay, and the town council is consulting residents about creating a legal wall near the skate park. Perhaps the heron has started a useful conversation after all.