C2 American · Text 12
Who Really Got Rich in the Gold Rush
A history professor tells the story of the California Gold Rush and asks why the people who sold shovels, food and work pants often did better than the miners.
47 sentences · Tap a sentence to hear it again
Text
Okay, let's get started. Last week we talked about the Mexican-American War, and I left you with a date: January 24, 1848. That's the morning a carpenter named James Marshall, who was building a sawmill for a man called John Sutter on the American River, noticed some shiny flakes in the water. He reportedly tested one by biting it. I don't recommend that as a research method, but it worked. Within a couple of years, California would be transformed, and today I want to ask a slightly uncomfortable question: who actually got rich?
The news spread slowly at first. Sutter wanted it kept quiet, because he was afraid, quite rightly, that his workers would abandon him, which they did. What really set things off was a shrewd businessman named Sam Brannan. Before he said a word in public, he bought up every pick, pan and shovel he could find. Then, so the story goes, he walked through the streets of San Francisco holding up a bottle of gold dust and shouting, "Gold! Gold from the American River!" Remember that detail, because it's going to come back.
By the end of 1848, the rumor had become a frenzy. In December, President Polk confirmed the discovery in a message to Congress, and in 1849 people began arriving in enormous numbers, which is why we call them the forty-niners. Over the next few years, about 300,000 people came to California, from the eastern states, but also from Mexico, Chile, China, Australia and Europe. San Francisco went from a small town of maybe a thousand people to a city of around 25,000 in roughly two years. The harbor filled with hundreds of ships whose crews had simply walked off to the gold fields, leaving the vessels to rot.
Now, the miners. In the very first months, when gold could be picked out of riverbeds almost by hand, some people made extraordinary sums, several hundred dollars in a day, at a time when a laborer back East might earn a dollar. But that easy surface gold ran out quickly. As more people arrived, the best spots were claimed, and the work became exhausting: standing in freezing water, shoveling gravel, washing it, again and again. By the early 1850s, the average miner was earning a few dollars a day, and many earned nothing at all. Meanwhile, prices in the mining towns were astronomical. Eggs could cost a dollar each. A shovel that sold for about a dollar in New York might cost ten in the hills. Plenty of forty-niners went home with less money than they'd set out with, and many others decided to stay and start again as farmers or shopkeepers.
So who did well? Overwhelmingly, the people selling things to the miners. Sam Brannan, our friend with the bottle, opened stores and became, for a while, one of the richest men in California. A young immigrant from Bavaria named Levi Strauss came to San Francisco to sell cloth and dry goods, and his company later became famous for tough work pants, the ancestor of just about every pair of jeans in this room. Others ran boarding houses, laundries, restaurants and transportation. A woman who baked pies and sold them to hungry miners could earn a steady income with far less risk than the men digging in the river. Historians have a phrase for this: in a gold rush, sell picks and shovels.
I want to be careful not to tell this as a simple success story, though. The Gold Rush was a disaster for Native Californian communities, whose land was taken and whose population fell dramatically in these years. Rivers were choked with mud from mining, and later methods washed away entire hillsides. Chinese miners had to pay a special tax on foreign miners that made their work far less profitable. So when we ask who got rich, we also have to ask who paid.
Here's where I'd like you to start thinking. Booms didn't end in 1849. Think about the dot-com bubble of the late 1990s, or any recent rush into a new technology. Many of the people chasing the prize lose money, while the companies that provide the tools, the servers, the equipment, the platforms, quietly make a fortune whatever happens. That's not a law of nature, and there are always exceptions, but it's a pattern worth noticing. For Thursday, read chapter nine and come with one example of a modern "picks and shovels" business. And no, you can't use Levi's. Everybody tries that.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| sawmill/ˈsɔːmɪl/ | a factory or building where trees are cut into boards |
| shrewd/ʃruːd/ | clever at understanding situations and using them to get an advantage |
| frenzy/ˈfrenzi/ | a state of wild excitement in which people act quickly and without control |
| vessels/ˈvesəlz/ | ships or large boats |
| gravel/ˈɡrævəl/ | small stones, often found in rivers or used on paths |
| astronomical/ˌæstrəˈnɑːmɪkəl/ | extremely high, especially about prices or amounts |
| dry goods/ˈdraɪ ɡʊdz/ | cloth, clothes and similar things sold in a store |
| choked/tʃoʊkt/ | so full of something that water or air cannot pass easily |
| bubble/ˈbʌbəl/ | a time when prices rise far too high and then suddenly fall |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.