Eenglish-tests.com

C2 American · Text 13

The Power of Defaults

A behavioral economist explains how the option you get if you do nothing can change what millions of people do, and asks who should decide what that option is.

55 sentences · Tap a sentence to hear it again

Text

Thank you so much. Before I start, a quick confession. For three years, I paid $12.99 a month for a streaming service I'd signed up for during a free trial, so that I could watch one documentary. I never canceled it. I'm a behavioral economist. I study exactly this kind of mistake for a living. So if you take one thing home tonight, let it be this: knowing about a bias doesn't make you immune to it.

My subject tonight is defaults, the option you get if you do nothing. Every form, every app and every website has them, and someone has chosen them for you. Carefully designed defaults are one kind of what we call nudges, a word made popular by the economist Richard Thaler and the legal scholar Cass Sunstein. A nudge doesn't forbid anything, and it doesn't change prices. It simply changes the way a choice is set up.

Let me give you the most famous example. In many American companies, workers can save for retirement through a workplace plan, where money comes straight out of their paycheck, often with the employer adding some money of its own. For years, the standard approach was opt-in: if you wanted to join, you filled out a form. And at a lot of companies, only about 40 percent of new employees ever did. Then some firms tried something very simple. They enrolled everyone automatically, at, say, 3 percent of their salary, and told them they could leave at any time with one phone call. Nothing else changed. Same plan, same rules, same freedom. Participation jumped to around 90 percent. After the Pension Protection Act of 2006 made automatic enrollment easier, thousands of employers followed.

Why does such a small change have such a big effect? There are at least three reasons. The first is plain inertia. Filling out a form takes effort, and the benefit is decades away, so we tell ourselves we'll do it next week, and next week never comes. The second is that people often read a default as a recommendation. If my employer has set me up at 3 percent, surely someone thought about it, so 3 percent must be sensible. The third is that once something feels like ours, giving it up feels like a loss, and we feel losses more strongly than gains of the same size. Put those together, and a default becomes remarkably sticky.

Defaults are everywhere once you start looking. When one university set its printers to print on both sides of the page unless you chose otherwise, paper use dropped by around 15 percent in the first semester. Cafeterias that put fruit at eye level near the cash register and move the cookies to a lower shelf sell more fruit, without banning a single cookie. And the next time a website asks you to accept cookies, the internet kind, notice which button is big and bright and which one is small and gray. That's not an accident either.

Now, here's where it gets uncomfortable, and I think we should be honest about it. If defaults are this powerful, then whoever chooses them holds real power. Take that 3 percent savings rate. It got millions of people saving, which is wonderful, but many experts think 3 percent is far too low to retire on. Because it was the default, a lot of people stayed there for years, assuming it must be enough. Some people who would have chosen 6 percent on their own simply accepted 3. So a well-meant default can still do harm. And the same tools that help people save can be used to sell them things they don't need, which is why critics call the bad versions "sludge" or "dark patterns." Think of a free trial that takes thirty seconds to start and forty minutes on the phone to cancel.

So who should decide? Thaler and Sunstein's answer, which they called libertarian paternalism, is that it's acceptable to steer people as long as they can easily choose differently and the steering is in their own interest. I'd add one test of my own, which I borrowed from a former student. Would you be comfortable explaining the default out loud, to the person it affects? If a company can say, "We signed you up because most people regret not saving," fine. If the honest explanation is, "We hoped you wouldn't notice," that's not a nudge. That's a trap. And there's no truly neutral option, by the way. Even a blank form is a design decision. So the question isn't whether we set defaults, but how transparently we set them. And now, if you'll excuse me, I have a subscription to cancel.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
immune/ɪˈmjuːn/not affected or harmed by something
nudges/ˈnʌdʒɪz/small changes that gently push people toward a choice without forcing them
paycheck/ˈpeɪtʃek/the money a worker receives from an employer, usually every week or month
enrolled/ɪnˈroʊld/officially made someone a member of a plan, course or group
inertia/ɪˈnɝːʃə/a tendency to do nothing and leave things as they are
sticky/ˈstɪki/here: hard to move away from once it is in place
semester/səˈmestər/one of the two main parts of a school or college year
paternalism/pəˈtɝːnəlɪzəm/making decisions for people because you believe it is good for them
transparently/trænsˈperəntli/in an open, honest way that lets people see what is happening

Tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.