C2 American · Dialogue 13
Checking the Facts
An editor goes through a young reporter's story about lead in a school's drinking water, number by number, and finds a problem.
27 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Paul Gordon:Emma, got a minute? I read your water story. It's strong. It's also not running Sunday. Not yet, anyway.
Emma:Paul, it's on the Sunday front page. The parents at Hilltop Elementary have waited three weeks for somebody to take this seriously.
Paul Gordon:Which is exactly why it has to be right. Walk me through the numbers. You say nine of the school's thirty drinking fountains are above the federal limit for lead.
Emma:Fifteen parts per billion. Nine fountains are over that.
Paul Gordon:Where does nine come from?
Emma:The parents' group. Denise Walsh, the PTA president, bought testing kits, thirty-five dollars each, and they tested every fountain in the building in October.
Paul Gordon:Did a lab analyze those samples, or did somebody read a color strip in the hallway?
Emma:They went to a certified lab in Cranberry Township. I have the lab reports, all thirty of them.
Paul Gordon:Good. That's solid sourcing. Now the scary one, forty-two parts per billion in the gym fountain. That's the number in your headline. Same lab?
Emma:No, that's from the district's own report. It was in the file Denise sent me.
Paul Gordon:Look at the date on the first page.
Emma:It says... 2019. Oh no.
Paul Gordon:And the gym fountain itself?
Emma:I'd have to check. Denise did mention that some fountains were replaced at some point.
Paul Gordon:The district replaced eleven fountains in the summer of 2020. I covered schools for six years, I remember the announcement. If the gym fountain was one of them, your headline is describing a pipe that doesn't exist anymore.
Emma:I can't believe I missed that. I was so focused on getting it out before the parents gave up on us.
Paul Gordon:Hey. This is what editing is for. You found something real. Nine fountains over the limit is still big news if it's true. But I won't put a number on the front page that I can't corroborate.
Emma:The city water authority is retesting this week. Their spokesperson told me the results should be ready Wednesday, but that was off the record.
Paul Gordon:Then here's my worry. If we run this Sunday and the city's numbers come back lower, we've frightened four hundred families for nothing, and we're printing a retraction on Thursday. Nobody remembers the correction. They remember the panic.
Emma:And if we wait and the numbers are worse, kids have been drinking that water for four more days.
Paul Gordon:That's a fair point, and it's why I'm not killing the story, I'm holding it. While we wait, call the district and ask, on the record, whether those nine fountains have been turned off. If they haven't, that's a question parents deserve an answer to, whatever the lab says.
Emma:Okay. And I'll go back through every number with Denise, line by line, so nothing else is from 2019.
Paul Gordon:Good. Also lose the word "poisoned" in your first sentence. The facts are worrying enough. If we sound alarmist, the people who need to act will stop listening.
Emma:Fair. Honestly, I picked that word at one in the morning.
Paul Gordon:Most bad words get picked at one in the morning. Look, if Wednesday's results back up the parents, this runs the following Sunday, top of the front page, with your name on it.
Emma:And if they don't?
Paul Gordon:Then you'll have a different story, maybe a better one, about why the parents and the city got such different numbers. Either way, you'll be able to defend every word.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| lead/lɛd/ | a soft, heavy gray metal that is dangerous to drink, especially for children |
| certified/ˈsɝːtəfaɪd/ | officially approved as meeting a set standard |
| sourcing/ˈsɔːrsɪŋ/ | where a reporter's facts come from, and how reliable those places are |
| corroborate/kəˈrɑːbəreɪt/ | show that something is true with more evidence from another place |
| off the record/ˌɔːf ðə ˈrɛkərd/ | said privately, not to be printed or used with the speaker's name |
| retraction/rɪˈtrækʃən/ | a public statement saying that something published earlier was wrong |
| holding/ˈhoʊldɪŋ/ | here: keeping a story back and printing it later |
| on the record/ˌɑːn ðə ˈrɛkərd/ | said officially, so it can be printed with the speaker's name |
| alarmist/əˈlɑːrmɪst/ | making people more frightened than the facts give them reason to be |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.