C2 American · Dialogue 12
The Bird Count
On a freezing December morning, an experienced birdwatcher and a young volunteer disagree about a distant hawk during the annual winter bird count.
31 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Frank Russo:Morning, Hannah. Six-forty on the dot, I like that. Ready for your first winter bird count?
Hannah:I think so. Two pairs of socks, a thermos of hot chocolate and the checklist. It's twenty-four degrees, right?
Frank Russo:Twenty-four, with the wind coming off the bay, so it feels more like fifteen. Our section is the north loop, about eight miles of marsh and woods. We drive a little, stop, look, and write down everything.
Hannah:Everything? Even the Canada geese?
Frank Russo:Especially the Canada geese. A common bird counted carefully is worth more to the scientists than a rare bird counted badly. This count has been running since 1900. People use these numbers to see which species are quietly disappearing.
Hannah:No pressure, then. Okay, what about that huge white band out on the water?
Frank Russo:Snow geese. Don't even try to count them one by one. Count a block of fifty, then see how many blocks fit.
Hannah:Fifty, a hundred... I'd say about sixty blocks. So three thousand?
Frank Russo:I had it closer to twenty-eight hundred, but you're in the right neighborhood. Write twenty-eight hundred.
Hannah:Frank, wait. The dead tree on the far side of the channel. That's a hawk, and it doesn't look like the others. Pale head, a dark band across the chest. I think it might be a Swainson's hawk!
Frank Russo:A Swainson's? In New Jersey, in December? That would be a real vagrant. They're supposed to be in Argentina by now. Hold on, let me get the spotting scope on it.
Hannah:Look when it stretches its wings. Dark along the back edge. That's exactly what the field guide shows.
Frank Russo:Okay. Large hawk, pale front, something dark across the chest. But the sun's right behind it, so half the time all I'm getting is a silhouette.
Hannah:The plumage looks right to me, though. How can it not be a Swainson's?
Frank Russo:Because a young red-tailed hawk in bad light looks a lot like that, and we've got hundreds of red-tails. How far away would you say it is?
Hannah:Five hundred yards?
Frank Russo:More like seven hundred. At that distance, everyone sees the bird they're hoping to see.
Hannah:So you think I'm imagining it.
Frank Russo:No, I think you might be right. But I've done this count for thirty-one years, so let me tell you a story. In 1998 I reported a gyrfalcon, right here. Arctic bird, huge deal. Three people drove down from New York the next morning to see it. It turned out to be a pale red-tail sitting in the fog.
Hannah:Oh no. That's painful.
Frank Russo:The compiler was very kind about it, but I've never forgotten. That was wishful thinking, pure and simple. A record has to hold up when somebody reads it in fifty years and wasn't standing here with us.
Hannah:I did get a photo through the scope with my phone. Here.
Frank Russo:Hmm. It's a brown smudge on a branch. In fairness, it does prove it's a bird.
Hannah:Fair. So what do we do, leave it off the list?
Frank Russo:No, we don't throw away what you saw either. We write "possible Swainson's hawk," with the time, the distance, the light and every feature you noticed. Then we tell the compiler tonight. If somebody else spots it tomorrow, your notes become very valuable.
Hannah:You know, that actually feels better than claiming it outright.
Frank Russo:That's the whole job, really. Be honest about how sure you are. Now, where are we on the list?
Hannah:Forty-five species, not counting the hawk.
Frank Russo:Then let's find number forty-six. There's usually a kingfisher by the bridge.
Hannah:There! Blue-gray, on the wire!
Frank Russo:Belted kingfisher. Forty-six. And nobody's going to argue about that one.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| marsh/mɑːrʃ/ | low, wet land where grass and reeds grow |
| vagrant/ˈveɪɡrənt/ | here: a bird that has flown far away from where it normally lives |
| spotting scope/ˈspɑːtɪŋ skoʊp/ | a small, powerful telescope on legs for looking at birds far away |
| silhouette/ˌsɪluˈɛt/ | the dark shape of something seen against a bright light |
| plumage/ˈpluːmɪdʒ/ | all the feathers of a bird and their colors and patterns |
| compiler/kəmˈpaɪlər/ | the person who collects everyone's results into one official list |
| wishful thinking/ˌwɪʃfəl ˈθɪŋkɪŋ/ | believing something because you want it to be true |
| hold up/hoʊld ˈʌp/ | stay believable and correct when other people check it |
| outright/ˌaʊtˈraɪt/ | completely and openly, with no doubt |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.