1Framing your case
Start where your listener is, not where you are. Before giving your proposal, name the problem or the goal you share: We all want fewer complaints, I know budgets are tight this year. When people agree with your starting point, they are more likely to follow you to the conclusion.
Opening and framing
| What you say | What it does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| I'd like to make the case for… | announces a clear proposal | I'd like to make the case for a four-day working week in the summer. |
| We all want…, so… | builds on a shared goal | We all want happier customers, so let's look at response times. |
| I know… is a concern, and that's exactly why… | turns a worry into a reason | I know cost is a concern, and that's exactly why I'm suggesting this. |
| The question isn't whether…, but how… | moves the debate forward | The question isn't whether we change, but how we do it. |
| Let me put it another way. | re-explains in a new form | Let me put it another way: every hour we save is an hour for clients. |
| What I'm proposing is… | a clear, simple statement | What I'm proposing is a three-month trial, not a permanent change. |
2Building the argument
A persuasive argument links each claim to evidence and to a benefit for the listener. Signposting phrases show the structure, so people can follow your reasoning instead of trying to work it out.
Evidence and reasons
| What you say | What it does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| The evidence suggests that… | careful, objective claim | The evidence suggests that shorter meetings lead to quicker decisions. |
| If you look at the figures, … | points to data | If you look at the figures, complaints fell by a third in the pilot. |
| A good example of this is… | makes the idea concrete | A good example of this is the Leeds office, which tried it last year. |
| What this means for us is… | turns facts into a benefit | What this means for us is fewer late nights before deadlines. |
| On top of that, … / What's more, … | adds a further reason | What's more, the change costs almost nothing. |
| Crucially, … | highlights the strongest point | Crucially, the clients themselves have asked for it. |
| It's not just about…; it's also about… | widens the argument | It's not just about saving money; it's also about keeping good staff. |
Notice the hedging in The evidence suggests… rather than This proves…. At C2 level, choosing the right strength of claim is part of persuasion: a slightly cautious claim that is clearly true is more convincing than a strong claim that the listener can easily attack.
3Anticipating objections
The most persuasive speakers raise the strongest objection themselves — before anyone else does. This shows honesty, takes away the surprise, and lets you answer the objection on your own terms. The pattern is: concede (admit the point has some truth) → counter (explain why your idea still works).
Conceding and countering
| What you say | What it does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Some of you may be thinking… | raises an objection first | Some of you may be thinking this will slow us down. |
| It's true that…, but… | concedes, then counters | It's true that the first month will be harder, but it pays off by month three. |
| Admittedly, … However, … | a more formal concession | Admittedly, the cost is higher at first. However, we save it within a year. |
| That's a perfectly reasonable concern. | respects the objection | That's a perfectly reasonable concern, and here's how we'd deal with it. |
| The risk is real, but it's manageable. | accepts risk without giving up | The risk is real, but it's manageable — we can stop the trial at any time. |
| If that does happen, we could… | a back-up plan | If that does happen, we could simply go back to the old system. |
4What people say to you — and how to answer
When you make a case, people will push back — often very politely. Recognise what is behind each phrase and answer calmly, without repeating your argument louder.
They say — you answer
| They say | You answer | Note |
|---|---|---|
| I'm not entirely convinced. | That's fair. What would you need to see to feel more confident? | Find out what evidence would change their mind. |
| Where's the evidence for that? | Good question. The pilot figures show… | Have your data ready. |
| It sounds good in theory, but… | I understand. Could we test it on a small scale first? | They doubt it will work in practice. |
| We tried something like that before. | I know — and we've learned from it. This time the difference is… | Show what has changed. |
| What's in it for us? | In short, less time on paperwork and quicker results for clients. | They want the benefit for them. |
| Let me think about it. | Of course. Shall I send you a one-page summary? | Make the next step easy. |
| I take your point, but the timing isn't right. | Would it make sense to revisit it in the spring? | Accept the delay but keep the idea alive. |
| Devil's advocate here: what if it fails? | Then we'll have lost very little, and we'll know for sure. | Playing devil's advocate = arguing against to test the idea. |
5Persuading politely and closing
End with a clear, easy request. A small first step (a trial, a pilot, a single meeting) is much easier to agree to than a big permanent change. Make the request a question so the listener feels free to choose.
Making the request
| What you say | Nuance | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Would you be willing to…? | polite, respects their choice | Would you be willing to try it for one month? |
| How would you feel about…? | soft, invites a reaction | How would you feel about a short pilot in one team? |
| All I'm asking is… | makes the request look small | All I'm asking is that we look at the figures together. |
| Wouldn't it make sense to…? | a stronger, persuasive question | Wouldn't it make sense to test it before we decide? |
| What have we got to lose? | informal, energetic | It's free and we can stop at any time. What have we got to lose? |
| So, to sum up, what I'm asking for is… | repeats the one clear message | So, to sum up, what I'm asking for is a three-month trial. |
6Useful words
Persuading
| Word | Pronunciation | Example |
|---|---|---|
| persuade | /pəˈsweɪd/ | She persuaded the head teacher to start a chess club. |
| convince | /kənˈvɪns/ | I'm not convinced it will work. |
| argument | /ˈɑːɡjumənt/ | That's a strong argument for the change. |
| evidence | /ˈevɪdəns/ | Is there any evidence that it helps? |
| objection | /əbˈdʒekʃən/ | Let me answer the main objection first. |
| concede | /kənˈsiːd/ | I concede that the plan has some risks. |
| compelling | /kəmˈpelɪŋ/ | She made a compelling case for the new library. |
| benefit | /ˈbenɪfɪt/ | The main benefit is that it saves time. |
| drawback | /ˈdrɔːbæk/ | The only drawback is the cost. |
| pilot | /ˈpaɪlət/ | We ran a three-month pilot in one school. |
| rationale | /ˌræʃəˈnɑːl/ | Could you explain the rationale behind the idea? |
| reservations | /ˌrezəˈveɪʃənz/ | I still have some reservations about the timing. |
| win someone over | /wɪn ˈsʌmwʌn ˈəʊvə/ | Her calm answers won the whole team over. |
| devil's advocate | /ˌdevəlz ˈædvəkət/ | Let me play devil's advocate for a moment. |
7Dialogues
8Being polite (British)
British persuasion relies on understatement and respect for the listener's choice. Phrases like I'd argue that…, It might be worth considering… and Would you be willing to…? sound modest, yet they are often more effective than strong claims. Over-selling (amazing, perfect, the best ever, you'll love it) can sound like an advert, and listeners stop trusting it.
Respect also means listening. Ask questions (What would make this work for you?), use the other person's words back to them (You mentioned staff time — here's how we'd protect it), and accept a "not yet" gracefully. A polite Would it make sense to revisit it in the spring? keeps the door open; arguing until the other person gives in usually closes it.
- ✗
Trust me, this is the best idea ever. You'll love it.
Over-selling; it sounds like an advert.
- ✓
I'd argue that this is the most realistic option we have.
- ✗
You have to say yes today.
Pressure; listeners resist it.
- ✓
How would you feel about trying it in one team first?
- ✓
That's a perfectly reasonable concern. If that does happen, we could simply stop the trial.