Eenglish-tests.com
C2

Giving and receiving feedback

Feedback is one of the most delicate things we do in any language: too blunt, and people feel hurt; too vague, and they never learn what to change. In English — and especially in British English — the line between honest and rude is drawn in a particular place, and much of the real message is carried by softeners, hedges and the order in which things are said. On this page you will learn how to give specific praise, how to offer constructive criticism that people can act on, how to ask for feedback, and how to receive it gracefully, even when you disagree. You will also learn to "decode" polite British feedback, where quite good may not be good at all. There are two dialogues and two tests at the end.

1Giving praise that means something

General praise (Good job!, Nice work!) is pleasant but tells the person very little. Specific praise names what was good and why it mattered, so the person knows what to repeat. It also sounds more sincere: people trust praise that shows you have really paid attention.

Praise: from general to specific

What you sayNuanceExample
I was really impressed by…warm, specific, professionalI was really impressed by how calmly you handled the client's questions.
What worked particularly well was…picks out one strengthWhat worked particularly well was the way you opened with a real story.
You did a great job of + -ingpraises a skillYou did a great job of explaining a difficult idea simply.
That made a real difference to…shows the impactYour summary made a real difference to the meeting — we decided in ten minutes.
I really appreciated the way you…personal thanksI really appreciated the way you stayed late to help the new team.
This is a really strong piece of work.overall praise for a report or projectHonestly, this is a really strong piece of work.
Keep doing exactly that.encouraging a habitYour emails are short and clear. Keep doing exactly that.

2Constructive criticism

Constructive criticism focuses on the work or behaviour, not the person; it is specific; and it points forward to what could be done next time. A widely used structure is situation → behaviour → impact → suggestion: In yesterday's presentation (situation), you read most of the slides aloud (behaviour), and some people stopped listening (impact). Next time, it might be worth using fewer words on each slide (suggestion).

Softening a critical point

What you sayEffectExample
One thing you might want to look at is…very soft; a suggestion, not an orderOne thing you might want to look at is the length of the introduction.
I wonder whether it would help to…indirect; invites the person to thinkI wonder whether it would help to add a short summary at the start.
It might be worth + -ingpolite adviceIt might be worth checking the dates with the venue.
I'm not sure this part quite works yet.honest but gentle; "yet" gives hopeI'm not sure this part quite works yet — the argument jumps a bit.
The only thing I'd say is…a small point after praiseIt's excellent. The only thing I'd say is the font is rather small.
Have you thought about + -ing?a question instead of an instructionHave you thought about splitting it into two shorter emails?
Next time, could you…?a direct but polite requestNext time, could you let me know if you're running late?
I need to be honest with you about…signals a serious pointI need to be honest with you about the deadlines — three were missed this month.

Notice that the level of softening tells the listener how serious the problem is. One small thing… means a detail. I need to be honest with you… or I'm a bit concerned about… means a real problem. Choose the strength deliberately: if everything is softened, a serious problem may be missed.

3Asking for and receiving feedback

Asking for feedback well is a sign of confidence. Specific questions get specific answers: What's one thing I could do better? is much easier to answer than Was it OK? When you receive feedback, the graceful response is to listen, thank, clarify, and only then respond.

Asking for feedback

What you sayWhen you use itExample
I'd really value your feedback on…a formal, sincere requestI'd really value your feedback on my first draft.
Could you be completely honest with me?inviting real criticismCould you be completely honest with me? I'd rather know now.
What's one thing I could do differently next time?a focused questionWhat's one thing I could do differently next time?
Did anything not land?informal: did any part fail to work?Thanks for coming. Did anything not land?
Would you mind having a quick look at…?a polite request for a reviewWould you mind having a quick look at my slides before Friday?

Receiving feedback gracefully

What you sayWhen you use itExample
Thanks, that's really helpful.accepting feedbackThanks, that's really helpful. I hadn't noticed that.
That's a fair point.admitting the criticism is rightThat's a fair point — I did rush the ending.
Could you give me an example?you need more detailCould you give me an example of where it wasn't clear?
What would you have done differently?asking for a concrete suggestionWhat would you have done differently in that situation?
I take your point, although…accepting part of it, adding your viewI take your point, although the client did ask for a long version.
I'll bear that in mind.promising to rememberGood idea. I'll bear that in mind next time.
Let me have a think about that.you need time before you answerLet me have a think about that and come back to you.

4What people say to you — and how to answer

British feedback is famous for being indirect. The words may sound positive while the real message is critical. The column "Note" shows what the speaker often means — the tone of voice and context will tell you how serious it is.

They say — you answer

They sayYou answerNote
It's quite good.Thanks. What would make it really good?"Quite good" with a flat tone often means "OK, but not great".
With the greatest respect, …Go on — I'm listening.Usually introduces strong disagreement.
That's an interesting approach.Do you have any reservations about it?May mean "I'm not sure it works".
I'd suggest you think about…Thanks — I'll make that change.Often a polite instruction: please do this.
Just a few minor comments.Great, thank you. I'll go through them today.Check them carefully; "minor" can be generous.
Not bad at all!Thanks, that's good to hear.Real praise: in British English this is warm.
Could we have a quick word?Of course. Now, or later today?Often a private, serious conversation.
Have you got a minute? I'd like to give you some feedback on the meeting.Sure — go ahead.Listen first; don't defend yourself at once.

5Disagreeing with feedback — gracefully

Sometimes feedback is wrong, or based on missing information. You may disagree — but defensive answers (That's not true!, It's not my fault) end the conversation. The graceful way is to acknowledge, give the missing context calmly, and invite a solution.

Responding when you disagree

What you sayWhat it doesExample
I can see why it came across that way.accepts their impression without accepting blameI can see why it came across that way, but the delay came from the supplier.
Can I just give you a bit of background?adds missing informationCan I just give you a bit of background? The client changed the brief twice.
I'd see it slightly differently.gentle disagreementI'd see it slightly differently — I think the short version suits this audience.
That wasn't my intention, but I understand the effect.separates intention and impactThat wasn't my intention, but I understand the effect it had on the team.
How would you suggest I handle it next time?moves the talk to the futureFair enough. How would you suggest I handle it next time?

6Useful words

Feedback

WordPronunciationExample
feedback/ˈfiːdbæk/Thanks for the feedback on my essay.
constructive/kənˈstrʌktɪv/Her comments were critical but constructive.
criticism/ˈkrɪtɪsɪzəm/He accepted the criticism very calmly.
praise/preɪz/The team deserves a lot of praise.
appreciate/əˈpriːʃieɪt/I really appreciate your help.
specific/spəˈsɪfɪk/Could you be a bit more specific?
strength/streŋθ/Clear writing is one of your greatest strengths.
area for improvement/ˈeəriə fər ɪmˈpruːvmənt/Timekeeping is an area for improvement.
defensive/dɪˈfensɪv/Try not to get defensive when people comment.
gracious/ˈɡreɪʃəs/She was very gracious about the mistakes.
tactful/ˈtæktfəl/That was a tactful way of saying no.
blunt/blʌnt/His comments were rather blunt.
reservation/ˌrezəˈveɪʃən/I have one or two reservations about the plan.
impact/ˈɪmpækt/Your story had a real impact on the audience.

7Dialogues

Feedback on a presentation
SSofia
Have you got a minute? I'd like to give you some feedback on this morning's presentation.
HHassan
Sure — go ahead. Could you be completely honest with me?
SSofia
Of course. What worked particularly well was the opening story — the whole room was listening.
SSofia
One thing you might want to look at is the slides. You read quite a lot of them aloud, and some people started checking their phones.
HHassan
That's a fair point. I was nervous, so I relied on them. What would you have done differently?
SSofia
It might be worth putting just a few key words on each slide and keeping the details in your notes.
HHassan
Thanks, that's really helpful. I'll bear that in mind for the conference.
SSofia
And honestly, for a first presentation, it was a really strong piece of work.
When you see it differently
MMr Wilson
Could we have a quick word, Aisha? The report for the client was rather long.
AAisha
I can see why it came across that way. Can I just give you a bit of background?
MMr Wilson
Please do.
AAisha
The client asked for every figure from the last three years, so I included them all.
MMr Wilson
Ah, I didn't know that. I take your point. Still, the key message got a little lost.
AAisha
That wasn't my intention, but I understand the effect. How would you suggest I handle it next time?
MMr Wilson
Perhaps a one-page summary at the front, and the full figures at the back.
AAisha
Good idea. I'll make that change before Friday.

8Being polite (British)

In British English, politeness in feedback is created mainly by three things: modal verbs (might, could, would), hedging words (slightly, a bit, perhaps, rather) and questions instead of statements (Have you thought about…?). A sentence such as You need to change this is grammatically correct, but between colleagues it can sound like an order from a strict boss.

Be careful with the opposite danger, too: so much softening that the message disappears. If a problem is serious, say so clearly, but calmly: I'm a bit concerned about…, I need to be honest with you…, This needs to be fixed before it goes out. Kind and clear is the aim. Finally, give critical feedback in private, and praise in public when the person is comfortable with it.

  • ✗

    This is wrong. Do it again.

    Blunt and gives no reason or direction.

  • ✓

    I'm not sure this section quite works yet. Have you thought about moving the example to the start?

  • ✗

    You always forget the deadlines.

    "Always" sounds like an attack on the person.

  • ✓

    Three deadlines were missed this month, and the team had to wait. Could we talk about what would help?

  • ✗

    Perfect, perfect, everything is perfect!

    Empty praise; it gives nothing to learn from.

Giving and receiving feedback: tests

Found this lesson useful? Share it with a friend or your class.