Eenglish-tests.com
B1

during, for or while?

During, for and while are all used to talk about time, and in many languages one word covers all three. In English, the choice depends on two questions: what comes next, and what question are you answering? For answers the question "how long?" and goes before a length of time: for two hours. During answers the question "when?" and goes before a noun: during the film. While also answers "when?", but it goes before a whole clause with a subject and a verb: while I was cooking. In this lesson you will learn each word, see them side by side, and practise the typical mistakes.

1Quick answer

WordMeaning and what followsExample
forhow long? + a period of time (two hours, a week, ages)I waited for twenty minutes.
duringwhen? + a noun (the film, the night, my holiday)My phone rang during the film.
whilewhen? + subject + verb (I was cooking, we were away)My phone rang while I was watching the film.
for + length of time · during + noun · while + subject + verb

So the quickest test is to look at the words after the gap. Is it a number of minutes, days or years? Use for. Is it a noun like the lesson or the summer? Use during. Is it a clause with its own subject and verb? Use while.

2for: how long?

We use for with a length of time to say how long something lasts or lasted: for five minutes, for three days, for a long time, for ages. It works with all tenses: past, present, future and present perfect.

TenseExample
past simpleWe lived in Manchester for six years.
present perfectI've known Emma for a long time.
futureWe're going to stay with Grandma for a week.
present simpleI usually read for half an hour before bed.
  • ✓

    It rained for three days without stopping.

  • ✓

    She's been a teacher for over twenty years.

  • ✓

    Can you look after my bag for a minute?

  • ✓

    We haven't seen our cousins for ages.

3during: when? + a noun

We use during before a noun to say when something happens. The noun is a period or an event with a name: during the night, during the summer, during the lesson, during the match, during my holiday. During can mean all the time from start to finish, or one moment inside that period.

MeaningExample
all through the periodThe shop is closed during the winter.
at one point in the periodI woke up twice during the night.
  • ✓

    Please switch off your phones during the exam.

  • ✓

    We met a lot of nice people during our holiday in Wales.

  • ✓

    Two players were hurt during the match.

  • ✓

    My grandad was a soldier during the Second World War.

During never goes before a number of minutes, days or years, because it answers "when?", not "how long?". We say for two weeks, not during two weeks. But we can say during the two weeks of the holiday, because "the two weeks" is now a particular, named period.

4while: when? + subject + verb

While has the same meaning as during, but it is a conjunction, so it goes before a clause with a subject and a verb. It often goes with the past continuous for a longer background action, while a shorter action happens in the past simple.

while + subject + verb: while I was cooking / while we were on holiday / while you sleep
  • ✓

    The phone rang while I was having a shower.

  • ✓

    Somebody stole my bike while I was in the library.

  • ✓

    Can you feed the cat while we're away?

  • ✓

    While Mum was cooking, Dad laid the table.

In shorter sentences, when both parts have the same subject, we can use while + -ing: "Don't use your phone while driving." = "... while you are driving." We can't use during + -ing here.

5Side by side

Often you can say the same idea in two ways: with during + noun, or with while + clause. Look at how the grammar after each word changes.

during + nounwhile + subject + verb
during the filmwhile we were watching the film
during lunchwhile we were having lunch
during my holidaywhile I was on holiday
during the lessonwhile the teacher was speaking
  • ✓

    I fell asleep during the film.

  • ✓

    I fell asleep while I was watching the film.

  • ✗

    I fell asleep while the film.

    The film is a noun → during the film.

  • ✗

    I fell asleep during I was watching the film.

    A clause (I was watching) → while.

  • ✓

    I watched the film for two hours.

  • ✗

    I watched the film during two hours.

    How long? → for two hours.

6Common mistakes

In Russian and Ukrainian, one expression meaning "in the course of" is used both for "how long?" and "when?". So learners often say during two years when English needs for. Another common problem is using while before a noun, or during before a clause.

7Memory trick

during, for or while?: tests

Found this lesson useful? Share it with a friend or your class.