Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 69 · Debate · 753 words

Work in an Automated World

An economist and a former print worker debate whether automation will make work more meaningful, drawing on history, economics and personal experience.

This is an edited transcript of a public debate held at a university in York. The motion was: 'This house believes that automation will make work more meaningful.' Speaking for the motion was Dr Amara Fenwick, an economist who studies technology and employment; speaking against was Owen Treharne, who spent twenty years as a union representative in the printing industry before becoming a writer. The chair was Callum Reid.

Callum: Dr Fenwick, you have the first word. Amara: Thank you. Every generation since the spinning machine has been told that this time the machines will take all the jobs, and every generation has been proved wrong. In 1930 the economist John Maynard Keynes predicted that his grandchildren might need to work only fifteen hours a week. He was right about rising productivity and wrong about what we would do with it: we invented new needs, new industries and new professions. Machines are very good at tasks that are repetitive and predictable. What remains – judgement, care, creativity, persuasion – is precisely the part of work that most people find meaningful. Automation doesn't hollow out work; it distils it.

Callum: Mr Treharne. Owen: I admire Dr Fenwick's optimism, and I'd like to share it. But she has described what automation could do, not what it usually does. When I started in print, a compositor was a craftsman. By the time I left, many of my colleagues were watching screens and responding to error messages. The machines didn't take the dull part and leave us the meaningful part; they took the craft and left us the supervision. And let's be honest about the Luddites, whose name is now used as an insult. They weren't foolish people who hated machines. They were skilled textile workers in the Midlands and the North who saw new machinery being used to cut their wages and their standing. Their complaint was not about technology but about who would reap its benefits.

Amara: May I come in there? I don't disagree about the Luddites – in fact, I think they've been badly maligned. But notice that the problem Owen describes is one of power and distribution, not of technology as such. The same machine can be used to deskill a worker or to free her from drudgery. Which happens is a choice made by managers, unions and governments. Owen: Then we agree that the outcome isn't automatic. But your motion says automation will make work more meaningful, as though it were a law of nature. My worry is that if we tell ourselves it's inevitable, nobody will bother to make the choices you describe.

Callum: Let's turn to care, which Dr Fenwick mentioned. Isn't caring the obvious example of work that machines can't do? Amara: It's the obvious example of work that people value. Software can now remind a patient to take medication or help a nurse with paperwork, which in principle gives the nurse more time to sit with someone who is frightened. That is what I mean by distilling work. Owen: In principle. In practice, I've seen the time saved by a new system swallowed up by a new target. If the hour you save is immediately filled with more patients, the work hasn't become more meaningful; it's become more intense.

Callum: We have a question from the floor. A sixth-former, Lily Ahmed, asks: 'What should people my age study if we don't know which jobs will exist?' Owen: Study something that teaches you to think, and join something that teaches you to organise. I'm only half joking. Amara: I'd say: learn to learn. The people who did best in earlier waves of change weren't those with the most specialised skills, but those who could adapt them. And don't neglect the subjects that look least practical. Understanding how people think and feel is unlikely to be automated soon.

Callum: Closing statements, briefly, please. Amara: The history of technology is not a story of jobs destroyed but of jobs transformed. I'm not asking you to be complacent; I'm asking you not to be fatalistic. Owen: And I'm asking you not to confuse a possibility with a promise. Automation can make work more meaningful. Whether it does depends on who is in the room when the decisions are made – and, at the moment, that isn't usually the people doing the work. Callum: Thank you both. Before the debate, fifty-two per cent of the audience supported the motion; afterwards, forty-seven per cent did. Mr Treharne carries the evening, though only just.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
productivity/ˌprɒdʌkˈtɪvəti/how much is produced in a certain amount of time or work
hollow out/ˌhɒləʊ ˈaʊt/take away the valuable inside part, leaving only an empty shell
distils/dɪˈstɪlz/reduces something to its most important part
compositor/kəmˈpɒzɪtə/a skilled worker who arranged letters and words for printing
standing/ˈstændɪŋ/a person's position and the respect they have in society
reap/riːp/receive good results, like a farmer gathering a crop
maligned/məˈlaɪnd/described in an unfair, unkind way
deskill/ˌdiːˈskɪl/change a job so that it no longer needs much skill
drudgery/ˈdrʌdʒəri/hard, boring work that has to be done again and again
inevitable/ɪˈnevɪtəbl/certain to happen; impossible to avoid
swallowed up/ˌswɒləʊd ˈʌp/used up completely, so that nothing is left
from the floor/frəm ðə ˈflɔː/from someone in the audience, not from the speakers
complacent/kəmˈpleɪsənt/too pleased with how things are to see possible dangers
fatalistic/ˌfeɪtəˈlɪstɪk/believing that you cannot change what will happen
carries/ˈkæriz/here: wins (a debate or a vote)

Work in an Automated World: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.