Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 51 · Essay · 777 words

What Is Beauty?

A reflective essay that weighs the answers of Plato, Hume, Kant and modern psychology to one of the oldest questions in philosophy, and ends with a modest suggestion of its own.

Few words are used so freely and defined so rarely. We call a sunset beautiful, and a proof in geometry, and a face, and a gesture of kindness; we are seldom asked what these things have in common, and if we were, we would be hard pressed to say. Philosophers have been asking the question for at least two and a half thousand years, and it is a measure of its difficulty that their answers have tended to multiply rather than converge.

For Plato, beauty was not in the eye of anyone. The beautiful things of this world – a body, a melody, a well-governed city – were, in his view, imperfect reflections of a single, eternal Form of Beauty, towards which the trained mind might rise step by step, as if climbing a ladder. The idea can sound austere, but it had the merit of explaining why beauty so often feels like a discovery rather than an invention: we do not so much decide that a thing is beautiful as find that it already is.

The opposing tradition is summed up in the proverb that beauty lies in the eye of the beholder. On this view, to call something beautiful is merely to report a pleasant feeling, much as one might report a liking for marmalade. The proverb is popular partly because it is so accommodating: it allows everyone to be right, and forbids nobody anything. Yet few of us really believe it. If a friend insisted that a scribbled shopping list was as beautiful as a Vermeer, we would not shrug and say that tastes differ; we would suspect that he was joking, or that he had not looked properly.

The Scottish philosopher David Hume saw the difficulty clearly. In his essay 'Of the Standard of Taste', published in 1757, he conceded that beauty is 'no quality in things themselves' but exists in the mind which contemplates them. Yet he refused to conclude that all judgements are equal. Some critics, he argued, are simply better placed than others: they combine delicate perception with long practice, freedom from prejudice and the habit of comparison. Their verdicts, gathered over time, amount to a standard – which is why works that have pleased across many ages and nations, such as Homer's poems, carry an authority that this season's fashions do not.

Immanuel Kant, writing in 1790, went further still. A judgement of beauty, he suggested, is peculiar because it rests on feeling and yet speaks as if it were about the object. When I say that a rose smells pleasant, I speak only for myself; when I say that it is beautiful, I speak, as it were, for everyone, and expect others to agree. Kant also insisted that such judgements must be 'disinterested': I may find a meal delicious because I am hungry, but my delight in a landscape owes nothing to any wish to own or use it. Beauty, on this account, is a pleasure we take in things for their own sake.

More recent attempts to pin beauty down have come from laboratories. Psychologists have found that people across many cultures tend to prefer faces that are symmetrical and close to the average, and that we take pleasure in patterns that are neither too simple nor too chaotic. Such findings are intriguing, but they explain rather less than they appear to. They tell us what we tend to like; they cannot tell us whether what we like is worth liking. A survey can discover that most people prefer a pleasant tune to a difficult one. It cannot discover whether they are right.

In the twentieth century, many artists grew suspicious of beauty altogether. It seemed to them too comfortable, too closely bound up with decoration and good manners, to answer to a century of upheaval. Some critics declared the word obsolete. The eclipse proved temporary. Beauty has a way of returning, not least because people never stopped needing it; one has only to watch the crowds that gather in front of certain paintings, or the silence that falls when a particular piece of music begins.

Perhaps the most honest conclusion is that beauty resists definition because it is not one thing but a family of experiences – related, as Wittgenstein might have said, by overlapping resemblances rather than by a single shared essence. What unites them is less a property of objects than a kind of attention: a moment in which we stop wanting anything from the world and simply look. If that is so, the question 'What is beauty?' may matter less than a humbler one: when did you last allow yourself to notice it?

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
hard pressed/ˌhɑːd ˈprest/finding something very difficult to do
converge/kənˈvɜːdʒ/to come together and meet at one point
austere/ɒˈstɪə/severe and plain, without anything to make it warm or comfortable
beholder/bɪˈhəʊldə/the person who is looking at something
accommodating/əˈkɒmədeɪtɪŋ/willing to fit in with everyone's wishes
conceded/kənˈsiːdɪd/admitted that something is true, often unwillingly
contemplates/ˈkɒntəmpleɪts/looks at or thinks about something carefully and quietly
verdicts/ˈvɜːdɪkts/judgements or decisions made after careful thought
disinterested/dɪˈsɪntrəstɪd/not influenced by any personal wish to gain or use something
pin beauty down/ˌpɪn ˈbjuːti ˈdaʊn/to say exactly what beauty is
intriguing/ɪnˈtriːɡɪŋ/very interesting because it is unusual or puzzling
upheaval/ʌpˈhiːvəl/a time of great and sudden change and disorder
obsolete/ˈɒbsəliːt/no longer useful or used because something newer has replaced it
eclipse/ɪˈklɪps/a period when something loses its importance or is forgotten
essence/ˈesəns/the most basic quality that makes a thing what it is

What Is Beauty?: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.