Good evening, and thank you for braving the wind to be here. It seems fitting to talk about the Gothic in Whitby, a town whose ruined abbey on the cliff has been brooding over the harbour for centuries, and where Bram Stoker, on holiday in 1890, found some of the material that would become Dracula. I want to suggest tonight that the Gothic is not merely a collection of props – castles, storms, secret passages, mysterious portraits – but a way of thinking about fear, and about what a society would rather not look at directly.
The story conventionally begins in 1764, when Horace Walpole published The Castle of Otranto. With a disingenuousness that would become typical of the genre, he first presented it as a translation of an ancient Italian manuscript, admitting his authorship only once the book had proved successful. The novel itself is preposterous in places – a gigantic helmet falls from the sky in the opening chapter – but it established a template: an ancient building, a tyrant, a persecuted heroine, and a past that refuses to stay buried.
Why should readers in the Age of Reason have wanted such things? One answer lies in the idea of the sublime, which the philosopher Edmund Burke explored in 1757. Burke argued that vastness, darkness and danger, experienced from a position of safety, could produce a kind of 'delightful horror' more powerful than any pleasure in mere beauty. The Gothic novel offered precisely that: terror at a safe distance, in the comfort of one's own armchair. It is no accident that the genre flourished at a time when science and reason seemed to be banishing mystery from the world. The Gothic was, in part, a return of the repressed.
Ann Radcliffe, the most popular novelist of the 1790s, refined the formula. In The Mysteries of Udolpho her heroine trembles through dark corridors, yet almost every apparently supernatural event is eventually given a rational explanation. Critics have sometimes found this anticlimactic; I find it revealing. Radcliffe allows her readers to enjoy the shiver of the uncanny while reassuring them, in the final chapters, that the world is orderly after all. Jane Austen, in Northanger Abbey, gently mocked readers who confused such novels with life – though it is worth noticing that her heroine's suspicions, while wrong in detail, are not wholly wrong about the character of her host.
The nineteenth century moved the terror indoors – and then inside the self. Mary Shelley began Frankenstein during a wet summer near Geneva in 1816, when a group of friends agreed to write ghost stories. The result, published in 1818, keeps the Gothic atmosphere but changes its source of fear: the creature is not a ghost from the past but a product of modern ambition. Later in the century, Robert Louis Stevenson's Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde located the horror within a respectable gentleman. The haunted castle had become the divided mind.
What unites these works, I think, is a fascination with thresholds: between life and death, past and present, the civilised and the wild, the self we show and the self we hide. Gothic fiction places its characters at such boundaries and then dissolves them. That is why the genre has proved so adaptable. Each age supplies its own anxieties – about science, about cities, about inheritance, about technology – and the Gothic gives them a shape, a setting and a face.
It would be easy to dismiss all this as cheap thrills, and certainly the genre has produced its share of lurid nonsense. But the best Gothic writing performs a serious function. It lets us rehearse our fears in a form we can survive, and it reminds us that progress does not abolish darkness; it merely moves it somewhere less visible. A culture that has no Gothic, one might say, is a culture that has stopped admitting it is afraid.
So when you walk back down the hundred and ninety-nine steps tonight, and the abbey looms above you in the dark, I hope you will allow yourselves a small, pleasurable shiver. Burke would approve. And then, I hope, you will ask the more interesting question: what, exactly, is it that we are afraid of?