Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 15 · Essay · 778 words

The Essay as a Form

An essay about the essay itself, from Montaigne's 'attempts' and Bacon's maxims to Woolf, Orwell and the video essay, asking what makes the form so hard to define and so durable.

In 1580 a French nobleman who had withdrawn from public life to the library in his tower published two volumes of short prose pieces and called them, with disarming modesty, 'attempts'. Michel de Montaigne's choice of word – the French for a trial or test – gave a name to a form that has been with us ever since. Yet the essay remains curiously hard to define. It is not a story, though it may tell one; not a sermon, though it may moralise; not a scientific paper, though it may reason with great care. Perhaps the best way to understand it is to take Montaigne's title at its word.

An attempt is something that might fail. This is the essay's most distinctive quality: it thinks in public, and it does not pretend to have reached its conclusion before it starts. Montaigne wrote about friendship, cannibals, thumbs, idleness and the education of children, and he changed his mind as he went, adding new passages in later editions without removing the old ones, so that his book became a record of a mind in motion. His famous question – what do I know? – is less a confession of ignorance than a method. The essayist begins with doubt and treats it as a vantage point rather than an embarrassment.

Within two decades the form had crossed the Channel. Francis Bacon's Essays, first published in 1597, borrowed Montaigne's word but not his temperament. Bacon's essays are compressed, aphoristic and confident; they read like advice from a statesman who has no time to waste. 'Of Studies' can be read in a few minutes and remembered for a lifetime. Between Montaigne's meandering self-examination and Bacon's polished maxims, the essay acquired from the start two contrasting personalities, and English writers have moved between them ever since.

The eighteenth and nineteenth centuries brought the periodical essay, written for magazines and newspapers. Joseph Addison and Richard Steele addressed a growing middle-class readership in The Spectator; Charles Lamb and William Hazlitt brought a new intimacy and wit to the form. In the twentieth century, Virginia Woolf wrote essays that move with the freedom of her fiction, and George Orwell, in 'Politics and the English Language', showed how an essay could be both a personal reflection and a call to action. What links these very different writers is a voice: the sense of a particular person thinking, rather than an institution pronouncing.

The German philosopher Theodor Adorno, in an essay whose title this piece echoes, argued that the essay's refusal to be systematic is not a weakness but a form of intellectual honesty. A system claims to have accounted for everything; an essay admits that it has not. It begins in the middle, chooses its examples freely and stops when it has said what it can, not when the subject is exhausted. To readers trained to expect a thesis, three supporting points and a conclusion, this can look like indiscipline. To its admirers, it is a more faithful picture of how thinking actually happens.

There is an irony here that every student knows. The school or university essay, with its word limits, marking criteria and required structure, often seems the opposite of everything Montaigne stood for. The comparison is a little unfair: learning to build an argument is valuable, and even Montaigne had read his classics. But something is lost when the essay becomes a genre in which the writer must never sound uncertain. The best student essays, examiners often say, are those in which one can hear a mind genuinely working something out – which is to say, the ones that remember what the word originally meant.

Today the form is flourishing in unexpected places. Long-form journalism, personal blogs and the 'video essay' all lay claim to the name, with varying justification. Some of this is merely opinion in a hurry. But much of it preserves the essential impulse: to take a subject – a painting, an illness, a walk, a word – and turn it over until it yields more than it seemed to contain. The essay's elasticity is the source of its survival. It can be a page long or a book long, comic or grave, personal or public, and it can absorb new media without losing its character.

What, then, is an essay? Perhaps simply this: a piece of writing in which the process of thought is part of the point. A report tells you what was found; an essay lets you watch the finding. That is why the form so often rewards rereading, and why, more than four centuries after Montaigne climbed the stairs to his library, we are still making attempts.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
disarming/dɪsˈɑːmɪŋ/making people feel friendly and less critical
sermon/ˈsɜːmən/a talk about religion or about how people should behave
moralise/ˈmɒrəlaɪz/tell people what is right and wrong
vantage point/ˈvɑːntɪdʒ pɔɪnt/a position from which you can see or understand things well
temperament/ˈtemprəmənt/a person's natural character and way of reacting
aphoristic/ˌæfəˈrɪstɪk/made of short, clever sentences that express a general truth
meandering/miˈændərɪŋ/moving slowly in many directions, like a winding river
maxims/ˈmæksɪmz/short statements of a rule or piece of advice
periodical/ˌpɪəriˈɒdɪkəl/appearing regularly, like a weekly magazine
intimacy/ˈɪntɪməsi/a warm, personal, close feeling
indiscipline/ɪnˈdɪsəplɪn/a lack of order and control
genre/ˈʒɒnrə/a type of writing, art or music with its own features
impulse/ˈɪmpʌls/a strong wish or urge to do something
yields/jiːldz/produces or gives
elasticity/ˌiːlæˈstɪsəti/the ability to stretch and change shape
grave/ɡreɪv/serious

The Essay as a Form: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.