Two thousand years after its heyday, Stoicism is enjoying an unlikely renaissance. Its maxims circulate on social media, its classics sell steadily in paperback, and its vocabulary turns up in self-help books and sports changing rooms alike. We asked Dr Ruth Calloway, who teaches classics in Exeter and is writing a book on ancient philosophy and modern life, whether the revival does the ancient school justice.
Interviewer: Let's start with the basics. Where does Stoicism come from? Ruth: From Athens, around 300 BC. Its founder, Zeno of Citium, taught in a painted colonnade called the Stoa Poikile – hence the name. Over the next five centuries the school spread across the Greek and Roman world. The three writers most people read today all lived under the Roman Empire: Seneca, a statesman and playwright; Epictetus, who was born into slavery and became a celebrated teacher; and the emperor Marcus Aurelius, whose Meditations were private notes, written in Greek, that he almost certainly never intended anyone else to read.
Interviewer: What is the central idea? Ruth: It's there in the opening line of the Handbook, the summary of Epictetus's teaching compiled by his student Arrian: some things are up to us and some are not. Our judgements, intentions and responses are up to us; our reputation, our health, other people's behaviour and the weather are not, or at least not entirely. A great deal of misery, the Stoics thought, comes from staking our peace of mind on the second category. They also believed that we are disturbed not by events themselves but by the judgements we form about them. That insight travelled a long way. In the twentieth century, the pioneers of what became cognitive behavioural therapy, including Albert Ellis and Aaron Beck, openly acknowledged the debt.
Interviewer: The popular image of a stoic is someone with a stiff upper lip who feels nothing. Is that fair? Ruth: It's the most persistent misunderstanding. Lower-case 'stoic' has come to mean grimly suppressing emotion, but the ancient Stoics weren't aiming at numbness. They wanted to be free of destructive passions – rage, terror, envy – which they saw as the product of mistaken judgements. In their place they hoped to cultivate what they called good feelings: a calm joy, a reasoned caution, genuine goodwill towards others. Marcus Aurelius is forever reminding himself to be patient with difficult colleagues. That isn't the voice of someone who doesn't care; it's the voice of someone who cares and is trying not to be consumed by it.
Interviewer: Why do you think it appeals now? Ruth: Partly because it's practical. It offers exercises rather than abstractions: picturing difficulties in advance, reviewing the day each evening, imagining how small one's worries look from a great height – what modern scholars call 'the view from above'. And partly, I suspect, because many people feel overwhelmed by forces they can't control, from global events to the endless churn of the news. A philosophy that says, 'Concentrate on what is yours to change,' is bound to be attractive.
Interviewer: Are there dangers in the revival? Ruth: Two, mainly. The first is that Stoicism gets repackaged as a productivity technique – a way to become a more efficient, less easily rattled employee. The ancient Stoics would have found that odd. For them the only true good was virtue: wisdom, justice, courage and self-control. Wealth and success were, at best, 'preferred indifferents' – things it is reasonable to want but foolish to depend on. The second danger is quietism. If you tell yourself that injustice in the world isn't 'up to you', you may simply stop trying to change it. The Stoics would have rejected that reading too. They thought of human beings as citizens of the world with duties to one another; Marcus spent his life governing, not retreating.
Interviewer: And Seneca? He's sometimes accused of hypocrisy. Ruth: With reason. He praised simple living while being one of the richest men in Rome. But I find that oddly reassuring. Stoicism never claimed that its followers were sages; it described an ideal to strive towards. Seneca's letters are full of a man admitting how far he falls short. If anything, that makes him better company than a flawless guru would be. Interviewer: Last question. If a reader wanted to try one Stoic practice this week, what would you suggest? Ruth: The evening review. Before bed, ask what went well, what went badly and what you would do differently – then let it go. It takes five minutes, and it's remarkably hard to do honestly.