On a Saturday morning the market square of the town where I grew up performs a kind of daily miracle that nobody notices. A man sells olives from a van beside the war memorial. Two elderly women share a bench and a flask of tea. A group of teenagers practise skateboard tricks on the steps of the old corn exchange, watched with weary tolerance by a pigeon. A street musician plays the same three songs he has played for a decade. None of these people chose one another's company, and most will never exchange a word. Yet for a few hours they share a space that belongs, in some sense, to all of them. That sense is harder to define than it looks.
The idea is ancient. In Athens, the agora was at once a market, a meeting place and a stage for argument; in Rome, the forum played a similar part. Centuries later, the coffee houses of seventeenth- and eighteenth-century London became places where people of different ranks could sit at the same table, read the news and dispute it, so much so that they were nicknamed 'penny universities'. What these places had in common was not beauty or size but porousness: anyone could walk in, and the mixing of strangers was the point rather than an unfortunate side effect.
Public space, in this tradition, is where a society practises being a society. The American writer Jane Jacobs, in her celebrated book of 1961, argued that busy streets are kept safe less by police than by the ordinary 'eyes on the street' of shopkeepers, residents and passers-by. Her insight was that order in a city is often a by-product of liveliness, not of control. A square that is used by many kinds of people at many hours of the day tends to look after itself.
But not every space that looks public is public. In many British cities, new squares and plazas have been built and managed by private developers, open to the public by permission rather than by right. Most visitors would never notice the difference until they were told, politely, that they could not hand out leaflets, take photographs with a tripod or sit on the steps for too long. Defenders of such arrangements point out that private management often brings better cleaning, lighting and security, and that without investment the space might not exist at all. Critics reply that a place where the rules are set by an owner rather than by the public is a shopping centre without a roof, and that the right to be in a place should not depend on being a likely customer.
A similar argument surrounds what is sometimes called 'defensive' design: benches divided by armrests so that nobody can lie down, metal studs on low walls, music played at certain stations to deter people from lingering. Sunita Bains, who has managed town centres in the north-west for fifteen years, is candid about the dilemmas. 'Every choice we make includes someone and excludes someone else,' she says. 'Shopkeepers want people to feel safe. Older residents want somewhere to sit. Teenagers want somewhere to be that isn't a shop. You can't please everyone, but you can at least admit who you're choosing not to please.' Her own preference, she says, is to design for more use rather than less: more seating, more events, longer hours, so that problems are crowded out rather than pushed elsewhere.
The teenagers on the corn exchange steps illustrate her point. In some towns, groups of young people are routinely 'moved on', treated less as citizens than as a nuisance to be managed. Callum, sixteen, who has skated in the square since he was eleven, puts it simply: 'We're not causing trouble. We just haven't got anywhere else to go that doesn't cost money.' His observation goes to the heart of the matter. A truly public space is one of the few places left where you can be present without paying, buying or justifying yourself.
It has become common to describe social media as the new public square, and the comparison has some force: online, too, strangers meet, argue and eavesdrop on one another. Yet the physical square offers something a screen cannot. It obliges us to share space with people we did not choose and cannot block, to see their faces, to hear the musician we would never have selected. That small daily discomfort may be one of the quieter foundations of tolerance.
By early afternoon the olive van has gone, the women have finished their tea and the musician is packing up. Nothing remarkable has happened, which is precisely what is remarkable. A few hundred strangers have shared a place, made room for one another and left it more or less as they found it. It is easy to take such ordinary civility for granted. Whether we continue to build, protect and fund the places where it can happen is a decision that every town, sooner or later, must make.