Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 39 · Debate · 737 words

Global Citizenship

A philosopher and a writer on local life debate whether it makes sense to call ourselves citizens of the world.

When Diogenes, the ancient Greek philosopher, was asked where he came from, he is said to have replied that he was a citizen of the world. The remark was meant to startle, and more than two thousand years later it still divides opinion. On a recent edition of a radio programme about ideas, the presenter Ruth Ainsley invited two guests to debate it: Dr Amara Mensah, a philosopher who teaches in Edinburgh, and Gareth Llewellyn, a writer whose books describe life in the small towns of mid-Wales.

Ruth Ainsley: Amara, let's start with you. Is 'global citizen' a serious idea or a pleasant slogan? Amara Mensah: A serious one, and an old one. After Diogenes, the Stoic philosophers developed it into something quite rigorous. One of them, Hierocles, pictured each of us at the centre of a series of circles: ourselves, our family, our neighbours, our fellow citizens and, finally, the whole of humanity. Our task, he suggested, was to draw the outer circles gradually inwards, to treat strangers a little more like neighbours. That seems to me not a slogan but a moral discipline. And it has practical force today. Diseases, pollution and the oceans don't stop at borders. Problems of that kind can only be tackled by people who see themselves as having obligations beyond their own country.

Gareth Llewellyn: I don't disagree with a word of the moral part. Of course a child in another continent matters as much as a child in my street. But 'citizen' is a particular word, and I think it's being stretched. Citizenship isn't just a feeling of goodwill. It's a set of rights and duties inside a political community: you vote, you pay taxes, you can be called for jury service, you can hold your representatives to account. There's no world parliament I can vote for and no world court that will hear my complaint about the potholes on the road to Llanidloes. To call myself a citizen of the world is a bit like calling myself a member of a club that has no rules, no meetings and no subscription. Amara Mensah: But institutions follow ideas, not the other way round. National citizenship itself was once an abstraction to people whose loyalties ended at the edge of their village. International agreements, shared scientific bodies, even the humble passport, are the beginnings of a framework. You don't need a world government to have world obligations.

Ruth Ainsley: Gareth, is there a danger in the idea, rather than just a weakness? Gareth Llewellyn: There can be. It's very easy to love humanity in general and neglect the neighbour who needs a lift to the hospital. Real care is usually learnt in particular places, with particular people, and a lot of it is unglamorous: sitting on the parish council, running the youth football team, knowing which elderly neighbour hasn't been seen for a few days. I worry that a vocabulary of global citizenship can make that local work sound parochial, as if it were somehow less enlightened than signing an online petition about a distant crisis. Amara Mensah: That's a fair warning, and I'd accept it. Nobody serious argues that we should love humanity instead of our neighbours. The Stoic picture keeps the inner circles. The question is only whether our concern stops at the edge of them.

Ruth Ainsley: Is there any common ground here? Amara Mensah: I think so. Some thinkers now talk about a 'rooted' cosmopolitanism: you belong somewhere, deeply, and that belonging is precisely what teaches you to respect other people's attachment to their own places. Gareth Llewellyn: I could sign up to that, as long as the roots come first. A tree with no roots doesn't spread its branches very far. It falls over.

Listeners' messages after the programme suggested the audience was as divided as the guests had first appeared. Several pointed out that young people increasingly study, work and make friends across borders, and feel global citizenship as a lived reality rather than a theory. Others argued that the phrase means most to those who can afford to travel, and that loyalty to a place is not a failure of imagination but a form of it. Perhaps the most thoughtful message came from a retired teacher in Shrewsbury: 'I've been a citizen of my town, my country and the world all my life,' she wrote. 'I never noticed that I had to choose.'

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
startle/ˈstɑːtəl/surprise someone suddenly
rigorous/ˈrɪɡərəs/very careful, exact and thorough
discipline/ˈdɪsəplɪn/a practice that trains you to behave in a certain way
borders/ˈbɔːdəz/the lines that separate one country from another
stretched/stretʃt/used in a wider way than its normal meaning
jury service/ˈdʒʊəri ˌsɜːvɪs/a duty to sit in court with other citizens and decide if someone is guilty
potholes/ˈpɒthəʊlz/holes in the surface of a road
subscription/səbˈskrɪpʃən/money you pay regularly to belong to a club or group
abstraction/æbˈstrækʃən/an idea that is general and not connected to real, solid things
unglamorous/ʌnˈɡlæmərəs/not exciting or attractive, but ordinary
parish council/ˌpærɪʃ ˈkaʊnsəl/a small local group of elected people who look after a village or small town
parochial/pəˈrəʊkiəl/only interested in your own small area, not the wider world
petition/pəˈtɪʃən/a written request signed by many people and sent to someone in power
common ground/ˌkɒmən ˈɡraʊnd/ideas or opinions that people who disagree both share
rooted/ˈruːtɪd/firmly connected to a place and its people
thoughtful/ˈθɔːtfəl/showing careful and kind thinking

Global Citizenship: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.