Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 94 · Panel discussion · 716 words

Panel: The Meaning of Work

A stonemason, a sociologist and a nurse discuss where people find meaning in their work, and what happens when work cannot carry it all.

This panel discussion was recorded at a community centre in Cardiff for a series on modern life. The chair, Priya Lal, was joined by three guests: Gareth Pryce, a stonemason who spent forty years repairing old churches and bridges; Dr Sunniva Hale, a sociologist who studies how people talk about their jobs; and Ellie Marchant, a nurse at a children's hospital.

Lal: Let's start simply. What is work for? Gareth? Pryce: For me, it was always about making something that would outlast me. When you replace a stone in a bridge that was built three hundred years ago, you're joining a long conversation with people you'll never meet. I've seen the chisel marks of a mason who died before Napoleon was born. Somebody will see mine one day. That's not a wage. That's a kind of company. Lal: Sunniva, does that match what you hear in your research? Hale: It's beautifully put, and I hear versions of it often, but I'd add a note of caution. Gareth's work leaves a visible trace. A great deal of modern work doesn't. A person who processes insurance claims or keeps a database tidy may be doing something genuinely useful, yet go home with nothing they can point to. If we define meaningful work as work that produces something lasting and visible, we quietly disqualify most of the workforce.

Pryce: That's fair. I've been lucky. Hale: Lucky, and also skilled. But my wider point is that we've loaded work with expectations it can't always bear. A century ago most people didn't expect a job to express who they were. They expected it to pay the rent and, with luck, not to injure them. Now we're told to find our passion and never work a day in our lives. I think that message is well meant, but it can leave people feeling that an ordinary, decent job is a personal failure.

Lal: Ellie, nursing is often called a vocation. Is that how you see it? Marchant: Partly. There are moments – a frightened child finally falling asleep, a parent who stops shaking because you've explained things clearly – when I can't imagine doing anything else. But I'm a little wary of the word 'vocation'. It can make it sound as if nurses don't need rest, or that caring about patients means you should never mention your own limits. The meaning is real. It just isn't a substitute for sleep. Hale: That's exactly the double edge I worry about. Meaning can sustain people, but it can also be used to ask too much of them. Marchant: Although I'd hate anyone to conclude that we should talk about meaning less. On a hard night shift, it's the only thing that gets you to the morning.

Lal: Gareth, you're retired now. What happened to the meaning when the work stopped? Pryce: (laughs) That's the question my wife asked, more or less, after about a month of me pottering round the house. Honestly, the first year was hard. I'd been 'Gareth the mason' for so long that I wasn't sure who else was in there. Then I started teaching evening classes in stone carving, and I realised that what I'd loved wasn't the job title. It was the attention – the hours of looking really closely at one thing. Hale: That's a pattern I see a lot. People who manage to separate their sense of worth from their job title tend to cope better with change: redundancy, illness, retirement. It doesn't mean caring less about the work. It means not putting every egg in one basket.

Lal: A final word from each of you. Is work where we find meaning? Marchant: It's one place. For me it's a very important one, but I find it in the people far more than in the tasks. Hale: I'd say work can offer meaning, but it shouldn't have to carry all of it. Friendships, families, hobbies and communities share the load. Pryce: I'll be the old romantic. I think nearly any work can be done with care, and care is where the meaning lives. A tidy database, Sunniva, can be a small cathedral if the person who built it was paying attention. Hale: (smiling) I'll pass that on to my research participants. Some of them will be delighted.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
outlast/ˌaʊtˈlɑːst/continue to exist for longer than someone or something
chisel/ˈtʃɪzəl/a tool with a sharp flat end for cutting wood or stone
company/ˈkʌmpəni/the pleasant feeling of being with other people, not alone
trace/treɪs/a mark or sign that shows something was there
disqualify/dɪˈskwɒlɪfaɪ/say that someone cannot belong to a group or take part
bear/beə/carry or support the weight of something
vocation/vəʊˈkeɪʃən/a job that you feel strongly you were meant to do, often helping others
substitute/ˈsʌbstɪtjuːt/something used instead of something else
double edge/ˌdʌbəl ˈedʒ/the quality of having both a good and a bad side
sustain/səˈsteɪn/give someone strength to keep going
pottering/ˈpɒtərɪŋ/doing small, unhurried jobs, often without a clear plan
worth/wɜːθ/how much you are valued, by yourself or others
redundancy/rɪˈdʌndənsi/losing your job because your employer no longer needs it
putting every egg in one basket/ˌpʊtɪŋ ˌevri ˈeɡ ɪn ˌwʌn ˈbɑːskɪt/depending completely on one thing, so you lose everything if it fails
cathedral/kəˈθiːdrəl/a very large and important church, built with great care

Panel: The Meaning of Work: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.