This debate was recorded at Kendal Library as part of a series called Thinking Aloud. The chair, Delphine Okafor, was joined by Hamish Cordery, a travel writer who has visited sixty-one countries, and Dr Anika Rowntree, a cultural geographer who studies how tourism changes small places.
Delphine: Hamish, you've made a living from travel. Is it still worth it? Hamish: More than ever, though perhaps not in the way we've come to practise it. I'm not defending the weekend dash to tick off a city. I'm defending the slow kind: going somewhere and staying long enough to become slightly boring to the people who live there. Some years ago I spent three months in a village in northern Portugal. For the first fortnight I was a curiosity. By the end I was simply the man who bought too much bread. That shift from spectacle to neighbour is where travel begins to teach you anything. Anika: I agree with nearly all of that, which is rather awkward for a debate. But Hamish is describing something very few travellers do. Most tourism, as I see it in my research, is the consumption of backdrops. People arrive at a place they've already seen a thousand times on a screen, photograph themselves in front of it, and leave. The place becomes scenery in a story about the visitor.
Delphine: Is that so terrible? Anika: Not in itself. Nobody should be scolded for wanting a nice photograph. But places aren't only scenery; they're homes. I've studied a small coastal town in Wales where, in August, visitors outnumber residents by roughly ten to one. The bakery sells out by ten in the morning, the lanes are blocked, and some families who've lived there for generations say they feel like extras in somebody else's film. The visitors aren't villains. They're simply arriving in such numbers that the thing they came to see begins to erode. Hamish: That's real, and I've seen versions of it. But I'd resist the conclusion that the answer is to travel less. The answer is to travel differently: out of season, for longer, to places that would welcome you rather than places that are overwhelmed by you. Anika: Which works beautifully until everybody reads your article and goes to the same quiet place. Hamish: (laughing) A hazard of the profession, I admit.
Delphine: There's also the environmental cost of flying, which many people now weigh up. How do you each think about that? Hamish: Honestly, and not comfortably. I fly far less than I used to, and when I do, I try to make the journey earn its cost by staying a long time. I'd rather take one long journey every few years than six short ones. Anika: I respect that, and it's roughly what I do too. But I'd like to add something that's less often said. Some of the most transformative journeys I've made were within thirty miles of my own front door. Last year I walked from one end of my own county to the other over a fortnight, and I met more strangers, and was more often surprised, than on most trips abroad. We assume that strangeness lives far away. Very often it lives at the end of the bus route, and we've simply never got off. Hamish: I love that, and I'd only say that it isn't a rival to travel; it's the same skill. Curiosity is a habit, not a destination. If you can't be surprised in your own county, a plane ticket won't cure you.
Delphine: So, to return to my first question: is travel still worth it? Hamish: Yes, when it changes the traveller more than the traveller's photographs. Anika: I'll accept that, with one amendment: when it changes the traveller more than it changes the place. And when the traveller has learned to say please and thank you in the local language. It's astonishing how much goodwill two words can buy. Delphine: A rare moment of consensus. Thank you both.