Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 34 · Review · 737 words

Civil Society

A critic reviews a new book on civil society, praising its portraits of clubs, charities and associations while questioning its gaps and its hesitations.

Somewhere between the family and the state lies a crowded, untidy territory that political theorists call civil society: the choirs, food banks, allotment associations, tenants' groups, parent-teacher committees and five-a-side leagues in which people meet as neither relatives nor subjects but as volunteers. It is, Eleanor Whitcombe argues in 'The Thick Middle', her absorbing new study, the part of public life we notice least and could least afford to lose.

Whitcombe begins, as most writers on the subject eventually do, with Alexis de Tocqueville. Travelling through the United States in the early 1830s, the French aristocrat was struck by the American habit of forming associations for almost any purpose – to build a church, found a school or campaign against a local nuisance. Where in France, he observed, one would find the government at the head of a new undertaking, in America one would find an association. These groups, he believed, were schools of democracy: in them, citizens learned the habits of cooperation, compromise and self-government that no constitution could teach on its own.

Her other lodestar is Edmund Burke, whose 'Reflections on the Revolution in France' praised love of 'the little platoon we belong to in society' as the first step towards a wider public affection. Between them, the French aristocrat and the Anglo-Irish statesman give Whitcombe the book's central claim: that a free society depends not only on laws and elections but on a dense web of voluntary bonds, which no government can create by decree and which, once frayed, are painfully slow to reweave.

The strongest chapters are those in which Whitcombe leaves the library. She spent two years visiting associations in four very different places – a former mining village in County Durham, a district of Glasgow, a seaside town in Kent and a commuter suburb of Bristol – and her vignettes are vivid without being sentimental. A brass band in Durham, its membership down to eleven, has survived by teaching anyone who turns up, including a retired GP who had never read music. A Glasgow tenants' group began over broken lifts and ended up running a homework club. What emerges is not a picture of heroic volunteers but of ordinary people doing unglamorous things together, and discovering, almost as a by-product, that they trust one another.

Whitcombe is less persuasive when she turns from description to diagnosis. Membership of many traditional associations has undoubtedly fallen over recent decades, and she lists the usual suspects: longer working hours, longer commutes, television, the internet, the professionalisation of charities that once relied on volunteers. But she is curiously reluctant to count the forms of association that have grown in the same period – online support groups, community energy schemes, mutual aid networks, running clubs that meet in car parks at dawn. One need not think these are perfect substitutes to suspect that civil society has not so much declined as changed shape.

There is a deeper difficulty, too. Civil society's admirers tend to write about it as though it were unambiguously benign. It is not. Associations can exclude as readily as they include; the cosy golf club and the neighbourhood committee that keeps out newcomers are civil society too. Whitcombe acknowledges this in a single, rather hurried chapter, but the acknowledgement sits uneasily beside the warmth of the rest. A fuller account would have asked what distinguishes the associations that widen a community's sense of 'us' from those that merely police its boundaries.

Nor does she fully resolve the book's most interesting tension: the relationship between civil society and the state. Some readers will take from 'The Thick Middle' the lesson that the state should step back and let volunteers fill the space. Others will conclude that associations flourish best where public services are strong enough to give them something to build on – the library that hosts the reading group, the school hall that houses the choir. Whitcombe seems to hold both views at different moments, and her even-handedness, though admirable, occasionally shades into evasion.

These reservations should not obscure the book's real achievement. In an age that tends to imagine public life as a contest between the lone individual and the vast institution, Whitcombe has written an eloquent reminder of everything in between. Readers will finish it with a fresh respect for the unpaid treasurer, the tea rota and the interminable meeting about the minibus – the unglamorous infrastructure of a free society.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
absorbing/əbˈzɔːbɪŋ/so interesting that it holds all your attention
lodestar/ˈləʊdstɑː/a person or idea that guides you, like a star used to find the way
little platoon/ˌlɪtəl pləˈtuːn/a small group of people you belong to (a platoon is a small group of soldiers)
by decree/baɪ dɪˈkriː/by an official order from people in power
frayed/freɪd/worn, with threads coming loose at the edges
vignettes/vɪˈnjets/short, vivid descriptions of a scene or person
sentimental/ˌsentɪˈmentəl/showing too much soft emotion, in a way that is not realistic
by-product/ˈbaɪˌprɒdʌkt/an extra result that you did not plan
diagnosis/ˌdaɪəɡˈnəʊsɪs/an explanation of what is wrong and why
the usual suspects/ðə ˌjuːʒuəl ˈsʌspekts/the people or things that are always blamed
substitutes/ˈsʌbstɪtjuːts/things used in place of other things
unambiguously/ˌʌnæmˈbɪɡjuəsli/clearly, with only one possible meaning
benign/bɪˈnaɪn/kind and harmless
police/pəˈliːs/(verb) control and guard, deciding who may enter
even-handedness/ˌiːvən ˈhændɪdnəs/fairness to all sides
evasion/ɪˈveɪʒən/avoiding giving a clear answer or decision
interminable/ɪnˈtɜːmɪnəbl/so long that it seems never to end
infrastructure/ˈɪnfrəˌstrʌktʃə/the basic structures that a system needs in order to work

Civil Society: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.