Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Text 12 · Article · 626 words

Why We Conform

An article about a famous experiment on group pressure, the reasons people go along with the majority and why conformity can be both useful and harmful.

In the early 1950s, the psychologist Solomon Asch invited a series of young men to take part in what they were told was a study of visual perception. Each volunteer sat at a table with several other people and was shown two cards: one with a single line, and another with three lines of different lengths. The task could hardly have been simpler – to say aloud which of the three matched the first. What the volunteer did not know was that everyone else at the table was working with the experimenter.

For the first few rounds, the group gave the obvious, correct answer. Then, as planned in advance, they all began to choose the same wrong line. The real participant, answering near the end, faced an awkward dilemma: should he trust the evidence of his own eyes, or go along with the unanimous verdict of the people around him? A substantial proportion of answers on these critical rounds followed the group, and most participants conformed at least once. Yet the findings are often reported selectively. A sizeable minority never gave in, and the majority of answers overall remained correct. Asch himself was at least as interested in people's capacity to resist as in their willingness to yield.

Why would anyone deny something so plain? Interviews afterwards revealed a range of explanations. Some participants said they had doubted their own eyesight and assumed the group must be right. Others knew perfectly well that the majority was mistaken but did not want to stand out or appear foolish. Psychologists now distinguish between these two forces. Informational influence occurs when we look to others because we are genuinely uncertain and believe they know better. Normative influence occurs when we go along with others in order to be accepted, even while privately disagreeing.

Later versions of the experiment showed how fragile the group's power could be. When just one other person at the table gave the correct answer, conformity dropped sharply, as though a single ally gave the participant permission to trust himself. When people were allowed to write their answers down privately rather than announce them, they were far less likely to follow the majority. Such results suggest that much conformity concerns public behaviour rather than private belief.

It would be a mistake, however, to regard conformity as simply a weakness. For a social species, paying attention to what others do is often an extremely sensible strategy. If you arrive in an unfamiliar town and see a long queue outside one café while the one next door is empty, following the crowd is a reasonable bet. Shared norms – from queuing to keeping quiet in a library – allow large numbers of strangers to live alongside one another with little friction. Children learn languages, customs and skills largely by copying the people around them.

The danger arises when the pressure to fit in silences people who have noticed a problem. In workplaces, committees and friendship groups, members may keep doubts to themselves because everyone else appears to agree – not realising that others are doing exactly the same. This phenomenon, often called groupthink, has been blamed for poor decisions in business and politics. Encouraging people to voice dissent, and making it clear that disagreement is welcome, can help.

Research has also shown that influence does not flow only from the majority. A minority that argues its case consistently and confidently can, over time, change the minds of many. Much social change, after all, begins with a handful of people who were willing to swim against the tide. Conformity, then, is neither good nor bad in itself. The question is whether we follow others thoughtfully, because their example makes sense, or unthinkingly, because we are afraid of standing apart.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
dilemma/dɪˈlemə/a difficult choice between two possibilities
unanimous/juːˈnænɪməs/agreed by everyone in a group
selectively/sɪˈlektɪvli/choosing only some parts and leaving out others
yield/jiːld/stop resisting and do what others want
informational influence/ˌɪnfəˌmeɪʃənl ˈɪnfluəns/following others because you think they know more than you
normative influence/ˌnɔːmətɪv ˈɪnfluəns/following others because you want them to accept and like you
fragile/ˈfrædʒaɪl/easily broken or weakened
ally/ˈælaɪ/a person who supports you and is on your side
bet/bet/here: a choice that is likely to turn out well
norms/nɔːmz/the usual, accepted ways of behaving in a group or society
friction/ˈfrɪkʃən/here: disagreement or trouble between people
groupthink/ˈɡruːpθɪŋk/when a group makes a poor decision because nobody wants to disagree
dissent/dɪˈsent/disagreement with what most people think or say
swim against the tide/ˌswɪm əˌɡenst ðə ˈtaɪd/do or say something different from most other people
unthinkingly/ʌnˈθɪŋkɪŋli/without thinking carefully about it

Why We Conform: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.