Most of us like to think of ourselves as reasonable people who weigh up the evidence before reaching a conclusion. Yet decades of research in psychology suggest that the mind relies heavily on mental shortcuts, and that these shortcuts, useful as they are, lead us into predictable errors. Psychologists call such systematic errors cognitive biases, and the word 'systematic' matters: these are not random slips but tendencies that appear again and again, in people of every age, culture and level of education.
Why should a brain that has served our species so well be so easily misled? The usual answer is that biases are the price we pay for speed. Our ancestors rarely had the luxury of gathering complete information before acting; a rustle in the grass called for a quick decision, not a careful analysis. Shortcuts that produced a reasonable answer most of the time were therefore valuable, even if they occasionally produced a wrong one. The difficulty is that modern life presents us with problems – statistics, investments, news stories – that our mental machinery was never designed to handle.
Perhaps the best-documented bias is confirmation bias: the tendency to notice, seek out and remember information that supports what we already believe, while dismissing whatever challenges it. A football fan who is convinced that the referee is against her team will recall every doubtful decision that went against them and quietly forget those that went in their favour. Confirmation bias is particularly powerful online, where we can easily surround ourselves with sources that tell us what we want to hear.
Another well-studied effect is anchoring. When people are asked to estimate a quantity, the first number they encounter, however irrelevant, tends to pull their estimate towards it. In classic experiments, volunteers who had just seen a high number gave noticeably higher estimates than those who had seen a low one, even when they knew the number had been chosen at random. Shops exploit this when they display a 'was' price next to a sale price: the original figure becomes the anchor against which the bargain is judged.
Then there is the availability heuristic, our habit of judging how likely something is by how easily examples come to mind. Because dramatic events such as plane crashes receive extensive coverage, many people overestimate how dangerous flying is, while underestimating far more common but less newsworthy risks. What is memorable, in other words, is not necessarily what is probable.
Ironically, learning about biases does not automatically protect us from them. Researchers have described a bias 'blind spot': most people readily recognise biases in others while believing that they themselves are largely immune. Indeed, intelligent people are sometimes better at constructing convincing arguments for conclusions they had reached for poor reasons.
None of this means that human reasoning is hopeless. Several strategies appear to reduce the effect of biases, at least in some situations. Deliberately considering the opposite – asking 'What would convince me that I am wrong?' – can weaken confirmation bias. Slowing down before an important decision gives more careful thinking a chance to override first impressions. Organisations increasingly use checklists, anonymous marking and 'devil's advocates' whose job is to challenge the group's assumptions. Perhaps most importantly, we can cultivate a degree of intellectual humility: an acceptance that our judgements, however confident they feel, may be flawed.
Seen in this light, cognitive biases are less a sign of stupidity than a reminder of how the mind works. They are the by-product of a system built for speed rather than precision. Recognising them will not make us perfectly rational, but it may make us a little more careful – and a little more forgiving of others who, like us, are only human.