A generation or two ago, a child with a serious food allergy was something of a rarity in a British classroom. Today, many schools have strict rules about nuts, staff trained to use adrenaline pens, and lunchtime routines designed around pupils' allergies. Nor has the rise been limited to food: hay fever, eczema and asthma have also become more common in many wealthy countries over recent decades. Why this should be happening is one of the more intriguing puzzles in modern medicine.
An allergy is, in essence, a case of mistaken identity. The immune system, whose job is to defend the body against genuine threats such as harmful bacteria and viruses, reacts to something harmless – pollen, a protein in peanuts, tiny flakes of skin from a cat – as if it were dangerous. The resulting reaction can range from a runny nose and itchy eyes to, in rare cases, anaphylaxis, a severe reaction that needs emergency treatment.
Part of the increase may simply reflect better diagnosis: doctors and parents are more aware of allergies than ever, so cases that once went unnoticed are now recorded. Yet few researchers believe that this accounts for the whole picture. The rise has been too rapid to be explained by changes in our genes, which points the finger at something in the way we live.
The best-known explanation is the hygiene hypothesis. In 1989, the British epidemiologist David Strachan noticed that children with several older brothers and sisters were less likely to develop hay fever. Perhaps, he suggested, early exposure to infections passed around in large families helped to train the immune system. The idea caught the public imagination, but it was often misunderstood as a claim that cleanliness itself is harmful. Many scientists now prefer a refined version, sometimes called the 'old friends' hypothesis. On this view, what matters is not dirt or illness as such but contact with the huge variety of microbes – in soil, in animals, in the countryside – alongside which humans evolved. Without these 'old friends', the argument runs, the immune system may be less finely calibrated and more prone to overreacting.
Crucially, this does not mean that washing your hands is a bad idea. Hygiene protects us from dangerous infections, and its benefits are beyond dispute. The microbes thought to be helpful are mostly those found in nature and in varied food, not the germs that cause disease.
Other factors are being investigated, too. Air pollution may irritate the airways and make them more sensitive. Spending more time indoors means less sunlight, and some researchers have explored a possible link with low levels of vitamin D. Food allergies, meanwhile, have produced one of the field's most striking findings. For years, parents were often told to keep foods such as peanuts away from babies. Large studies later suggested that, for many children, introducing these foods early – under medical guidance where a child is considered at high risk – may actually make an allergy less likely. Official guidance has changed as a result, showing how science revises its advice as evidence builds up. Parents with questions should talk to a doctor.
What emerges is not a single culprit but a tangle of interacting causes. Our genes may load the dice, while modern environments – cleaner, more urban, more indoor – seem to tip the balance. That is frustrating for anyone hoping for a simple answer, but it also offers grounds for cautious optimism. The more clearly scientists understand how the immune system learns what to tolerate, the better placed they will be to prevent allergies, rather than merely treat them.