Not so long ago, seeing a doctor almost always meant sitting in a waiting room. Today, for many patients, it can mean a phone call or a video consultation from the kitchen table. Telemedicine – the delivery of healthcare at a distance using technology – is hardly new: doctors have given advice by telephone for decades, and isolated communities have long relied on it. But during the COVID-19 pandemic, when face-to-face contact had to be limited, its use grew dramatically, and many services have kept it ever since.
For Callum Ross, a farmer on a remote peninsula in the Scottish Highlands, the change has been welcome. 'The nearest surgery is a long drive away, and in winter the road isn't always open,' he says. 'Being able to speak to someone on a screen means I don't lose half a day's work for a short appointment.'
Video calls are only part of the story. With remote monitoring, patients with long-term conditions can use devices at home to measure things such as blood pressure, and the readings are sent automatically to clinicians, who can spot worrying changes early. Photographs of skin problems can be reviewed by dermatologists many miles away, and specialists in city hospitals can advise local teams without anyone having to travel.
Dr Fiona MacLeod, a GP who has worked in the Highlands for many years, is enthusiastic but measured. Journalist: Can a video call really replace a visit to the surgery? Dr MacLeod: For some things, absolutely. Going through test results, reviewing a repeat prescription, a follow-up chat – those often work perfectly well remotely. But there are limits. I can't listen to someone's chest through a screen, or check a tender tummy. And so much of what a doctor learns comes from small things: how a person walks into the room, how they're breathing. Journalist: So who decides which kind of appointment a patient gets? Dr MacLeod: Ideally, it's a shared decision. We try very hard to make sure nobody is pushed into a phone call when they really need to be seen in person.
Critics also point to the risk of a digital divide. Not everyone has a reliable internet connection, a smartphone or the confidence to use one, and those least comfortable with technology – some older people, some people with disabilities, those who cannot afford mobile data – may also be among those who need care most. There are concerns, too, about privacy, and about whether patients who speak to a different clinician each time lose the continuity of a doctor who knows them well.
Supporters counter that these are reasons to design services carefully rather than to abandon them. Offering a genuine choice, providing phone as well as video options, and keeping in-person appointments available for those who prefer or need them can help to ensure that convenience for some does not come at the expense of others.
What seems clear is that telemedicine is neither a cure-all nor a passing fad. Used thoughtfully, it can save time, reduce travel and bring expert advice to places that once had little access to it. Used carelessly, it risks leaving some people behind. As Dr MacLeod puts it: 'The technology is just a tool. What matters is whether it helps the person in front of you – or, these days, on the other side of the screen.' Whatever the format, anyone with a health worry should not hesitate to contact their doctor.