On the wall of almost every school science laboratory hangs a chart that many students take for granted: the periodic table of the elements. Yet behind its neat rows and columns lies a story of guesswork, rivalry, ridicule and remarkable insight. The table was not discovered in a single moment of genius; it was pieced together over decades, as chemists struggled to find order in what at first looked like a random collection of substances.
By the middle of the nineteenth century, chemists had identified several dozen elements and were measuring their atomic weights with increasing precision. Some noticed intriguing patterns. Earlier in the century, the German chemist Johann Döbereiner had pointed out that certain elements appeared in groups of three with similar properties, which he called 'triads'. In the 1860s, the English chemist John Newlands arranged the known elements in order of atomic weight and observed that similar properties seemed to recur at every eighth element, like notes in a musical scale. When he presented his 'law of octaves' to a scientific society in London, he was met with ridicule; one member reportedly asked whether he had tried arranging the elements alphabetically. Newlands was later vindicated, and many years afterwards he received a prestigious award for his work.
The name most closely associated with the table, however, is that of the Russian chemist Dmitri Mendeleev. In 1869, while writing a chemistry textbook, he set out to arrange the elements in a logical order. According to a popular account, he wrote the name and properties of each element on a separate card and laid the cards out like a game of patience; another story claims that the final arrangement came to him in a dream. Historians treat such anecdotes with caution, but there is no doubt about what made Mendeleev's table special.
Unlike earlier attempts, it did not force every known element into place. Where the pattern seemed to demand an element that nobody had yet found, Mendeleev left a gap – and, crucially, he predicted the properties that the missing elements would have, from their atomic weights to the kinds of compounds they would form. He was even prepared to suggest that some accepted atomic weights must be wrong because they did not fit his scheme. It was a bold, almost reckless move. Had his predictions failed, his table might well have been forgotten.
Instead, they came true. Within about two decades, three of the missing elements – gallium, scandium and germanium – had been discovered, and their properties matched his predictions with impressive accuracy. Few things persuade scientists as powerfully as a successful prediction, and Mendeleev's reputation was secured. It is worth noting that the German chemist Lothar Meyer developed a very similar arrangement at around the same time, and the two men were later honoured together. Discoveries made independently by different people at the same time are surprisingly common in science, which suggests that some ideas emerge when the time is right rather than from one isolated mind.
The table was not finished, though. In the 1890s, the discovery of the noble gases, such as argon and helium, required an entirely new column – a sign of how flexible Mendeleev's framework was. Then, in the early twentieth century, the young English physicist Henry Moseley used X-rays to show that the true organising principle was not atomic weight but atomic number: the number of protons in an atom's nucleus. This explained the few awkward cases in which Mendeleev had placed elements out of weight order, confirming that his chemical instincts had been sound.
Today's table contains well over a hundred elements, the heaviest of which have been created artificially in laboratories and exist for only tiny fractions of a second. One of them, mendelevium, is named in his honour. Yet perhaps the table's greatest achievement is not its comprehensiveness but its power to explain. Its structure reflects the arrangement of electrons inside atoms, which is why elements in the same column behave in similar ways. What began as an attempt to organise a textbook became one of the most elegant summaries of knowledge ever produced.