Most of us regard forgetting as a failure: the name that slips away at a party, the French verbs that vanish the moment an exam is over. But a growing body of research suggests that forgetting is not simply memory breaking down. We spoke to Dr Rosalind Mercer, a cognitive psychologist at the University of York, about why the brain lets go of information, and whether we should be grateful that it does.
Interviewer: Where does the scientific study of forgetting begin? Dr Mercer: With a rather eccentric German psychologist called Hermann Ebbinghaus, in the 1880s. He memorised long lists of nonsense syllables, things like 'dax' or 'bok', and then tested himself at different intervals to see how much he had retained. He used nonsense deliberately, so that existing knowledge couldn't help him. What he found became known as the forgetting curve: we lose information fastest in the first hours and days, and then the rate of loss gradually levels off. Interviewer: That sounds rather depressing. Dr Mercer: It needn't be. Ebbinghaus also noticed that each time he relearned a list, he forgot it more slowly. That's the basis of what we now call the spacing effect. If you review material at gradually increasing intervals, rather than cramming it all the night before, it stays with you far longer. It's one of the most robust findings in psychology, and yet remarkably few students make use of it.
Interviewer: Why do we forget at all? Is it simply that memories fade? Dr Mercer: Fading, or decay, may play a part, but it's probably not the main story. A great deal of forgetting is caused by interference: new memories compete with old ones, especially when they're similar. If you've moved house, you'll know how your old phone number keeps getting in the way of the new one, or vice versa. Often the memory hasn't gone; we simply can't retrieve it. The 'tip of the tongue' feeling is a perfect example. You know that you know the word, but you can't quite reach it.
Interviewer: You've argued that forgetting is actually useful. How so? Dr Mercer: Imagine remembering every single place you had ever parked a car. Finding it today would be a nightmare. The brain needs to prioritise information that's likely to be useful and let the rest recede. There's even evidence that the act of recalling one memory can actively suppress competing ones, which helps us to retrieve the right answer more quickly. Forgetting, in that sense, is less a flaw than a filter.
Interviewer: Are there people who can't forget? Dr Mercer: A very small number of people have been described with an extraordinary memory for the events of their own lives. They can recall what they did on almost any date. You might expect them to regard it as a gift, but several have said it can be overwhelming, because painful memories remain as vivid as the day they happened. It's a useful reminder that a perfect memory isn't necessarily a desirable one.
Interviewer: So what practical advice would you give our readers? Dr Mercer: Test yourself rather than rereading. Retrieving information, even with effort, strengthens it far more than passively looking over your notes. Space your practice out, and get enough sleep, because much of the consolidation of memories happens overnight. And don't beat yourself up about forgetting things. It's a sign that your brain is doing its job, not that it's failing.