At a festival of ideas in York, three guests discussed what universities might look like in twenty years' time. The panel was chaired by the journalist Simon Achebe. His guests were Professor Helen Marsh, head of a university in the north of England; Kwame Osei, who founded an online learning company; and Priya Nair, a nineteen-year-old on a degree apprenticeship with an engineering firm.
Simon: Helen, critics say the traditional three-year degree is outdated. Is it? Helen: I'd say it's being tested rather than outdated. What a university offers isn't merely information – you can find most of that online for free. It's a community: arguing with people who think differently, working alongside researchers, learning to thrive without your parents nearby. That said, I accept that we've been too slow to adapt. Not everyone can afford to stop working for three years, and we need to offer far more flexibility.
Simon: Kwame, your company was built on the idea that learning can happen anywhere. Kwame: It was, and I'm unapologetic about that. Technology has made it possible for a nurse in Leeds or a farmer in Kenya to study with excellent teachers at a fraction of the cost. I think the future lies in shorter, stackable qualifications that people collect throughout their working lives, not in one expensive degree at eighteen. In fact, I'd go as far as to say that the very idea of "finishing" your education is already obsolete.
Simon: Priya, you chose a different route altogether. Priya: I did. I spend four days a week at work and one at university, and my employer pays the tuition fees. So I'm earning a salary, I won't graduate with debt, and I'm learning things I can apply the next morning. Having said that, I wouldn't recommend it to everyone. Some of my friends at university are studying philosophy or history, and those subjects need time and space to think, which an apprenticeship can't really give you.
Simon: Kwame, a common criticism of online learning is that people simply don't finish. Kwame: It's a fair point, and I won't dodge it. Many people who sign up for free online courses never complete them. But that's partly because they're free – there's little at stake. When learners have a clear goal and support from a real tutor, completion rates rise considerably. Helen: Which rather proves my point, if I may. What makes the difference is human contact. I'm not against technology – half our lectures are now recorded – but the most valuable moments in education tend to happen in conversation, not in front of a screen. Kwame: I'd push back a little there. A conversation doesn't need a lecture theatre. Some of the liveliest discussions I've ever seen took place on video calls between students on three continents.
Simon: What about cost? Many young people worry about debt. Priya: Honestly, that was a huge factor for me. I'd like universities to be more open about what students actually get for their money. Helen: I agree there should be more transparency. But I'd also caution against judging a degree purely by the salary it leads to. Education changes how people think, and that's hard to put a price on.
Simon: Finally, picture a university in 2045. What do you see? Helen: A campus that's still busy, but full of people of every age, coming back to learn throughout their lives. Kwame: Fewer buildings, more partnerships with employers, and learning that follows you wherever you go. Priya: More choice. I'd simply like eighteen-year-olds to know that there's more than one path, and that none of them is second best.