This is an edited transcript of a debate on a regional radio station in the West of England. The presenter, Ruth Adeyemi, was joined by Dr Tom Harland, conservation director at a zoo near Bath; Leila Sandoval, who campaigns for animal welfare; and Professor Gareth Lloyd, an ecologist at a university in Cardiff.
Ruth: Tom, let's begin with you. In the twenty-first century, why do we still need zoos? Tom: Because, for a growing number of species, there's nowhere else to go. Good zoos run breeding programmes that act as an insurance policy against extinction. The Arabian oryx, for instance, disappeared from the wild in the 1970s and survives today only because animals bred in captivity were returned to the desert. Zoos also fund conservation work in the wild, and they inspire millions of children who would never otherwise see a living rhino.
Ruth: Leila, you're not convinced. Leila: I don't doubt Tom's sincerity, and I'd be the first to admit that the best zoos have improved beyond recognition. But success stories like the oryx are the exception rather than the rule. Most animals in zoos belong to species that aren't endangered at all, and very few will ever be released. For many of them, life in an enclosure is a pale imitation of the life they evolved for.
Ruth: Gareth, where do you stand? Gareth: Somewhere uncomfortably in the middle, I'm afraid. I think the question "Should zoos exist?" is too blunt. It depends enormously on the species. Small amphibians, many reptiles and some birds can thrive in carefully designed habitats; indeed, some frogs now survive only in captivity because a disease has wiped out their wild populations. Animals that roam over vast distances are a different matter. Polar bears and elephants, in my view, simply don't belong in a city zoo, however well it's run. Tom: I'd partly accept that. Some zoos have already chosen to stop keeping elephants, precisely because they couldn't provide enough space. That's the kind of honest decision the whole sector should be making.
Ruth: Leila, what would you put in place of zoos? Leila: I'd like to see money channelled into protecting habitats in the wild, because an animal without a habitat has no future anyway. Where animals genuinely can't survive in the wild – injured ones, say – I'd support sanctuaries, which exist for the animals' benefit rather than for visitors'. And I'd argue that children can learn a great deal from wildlife documentaries and local nature reserves. Tom: With respect, a screen is no substitute for the real thing. I've watched countless schoolchildren fall silent in front of a gorilla. That moment of connection is what turns them into future conservationists. Leila: Is it, though? I'd want to see the evidence. A child watching a bored animal pacing up and down may learn exactly the wrong lesson: that it's acceptable to keep wild creatures for our entertainment.
Gareth: To be fair to both of them, the research on what visitors actually learn is mixed. Some studies suggest a lasting effect; others find that people mostly remember the café. What I'd say with more confidence is that the quality of a zoo matters far more than the label. A well-funded conservation centre and a cramped roadside attraction are both called zoos, but they're barely comparable.
Ruth: So, a final word from each of you. Should zoos exist in fifty years' time? Tom: Yes, but as conservation centres first and visitor attractions second. Leila: Only in a much smaller form, and with the long-term aim of making themselves unnecessary. Gareth: Some should, for the species that truly benefit. The rest, I suspect, will gradually fade away. Ruth: Three very different answers, then, but perhaps more common ground than we expected. Thank you all.