Climate change is usually discussed in terms of rising temperatures, but carbon dioxide is also quietly changing the chemistry of the sea. We spoke to Dr Isla Rennie, a marine chemist at a coastal research station in Cornwall, about a problem sometimes described as climate change's 'evil twin'.
Interviewer: Let's begin with the chemistry. What actually happens? Dr Rennie: The ocean absorbs a large share of the carbon dioxide we release by burning fossil fuels, which in one sense is a great service: without it, the atmosphere would be warming even faster. But when carbon dioxide dissolves in seawater, it forms a weak acid, carbonic acid. That lowers the water's pH, and the more carbon dioxide we emit, the further it falls.
Interviewer: So the sea is turning into acid? Dr Rennie: No, and that's a common misconception. Seawater is naturally slightly alkaline, and it will remain so for the foreseeable future. 'Acidification' describes the direction of travel, not the destination. However, the pH scale is logarithmic, so what looks like a small change in the numbers actually represents a considerable increase in acidity. And the change is happening far faster than anything marine life has experienced for a very long time.
Interviewer: Why does it matter so much to sea creatures? Dr Rennie: Chiefly because of shells and skeletons. Many organisms, including corals, oysters, mussels and some types of plankton, build their structures from calcium carbonate. As the water becomes more acidic, the carbonate they need becomes scarcer, so building and maintaining a shell takes more energy. In some conditions, shells can even begin to dissolve. Young animals tend to be the most vulnerable. Some oyster hatcheries on the Pacific coast of the United States have already suffered heavy losses of larvae when particularly acidic water welled up from the deep.
Interviewer: And the effects don't stop there? Dr Rennie: No, far from it. Tiny sea snails known as pteropods, sometimes called sea butterflies, are an important food for fish, whales and seabirds in colder waters. If they struggle, the effects could ripple through the whole food web. Coral reefs face a double threat, since they're already under pressure from warmer water. There's also research suggesting that some fish may find it harder to detect predators, though those findings are still debated.
Interviewer: Is there anything that can be done locally? Dr Rennie: To some extent. Reducing pollution and protecting seagrass meadows can help, because seagrass takes up carbon dioxide and can slightly ease conditions in the water around it. Hatcheries can treat the water they use for young shellfish. Scientists are also experimenting with adding alkaline minerals to seawater, but that's at an early stage and would need careful study. None of these measures, though, tackles the root cause.
Interviewer: Which is? Dr Rennie: Carbon dioxide emissions. Unlike warming, which might in theory be partly offset by reflecting sunlight, acidification can only really be addressed by putting less carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. That's what makes it such a clear warning sign: it isn't a forecast from a computer model, it's a measurable change that's already happening. Interviewer: Does that leave you pessimistic? Dr Rennie: Not entirely. The ocean has a remarkable capacity to recover if we give it the chance, and public interest in it has rarely been greater. What we can't afford is to treat the sea as an endless dustbin for our emissions. It's been doing us a favour for a long time; it's about time we returned it.