The following is an edited transcript from 'Common Ground', a radio programme in which guests with different views discuss environmental questions. This week, the presenter Rachel Dunmore talks to Gareth Lowe, an ecological consultant who advises developers, and Dr Sian Mercer, a conservation scientist.
Rachel: Let's start with the basics. Gareth, what exactly is biodiversity offsetting? Gareth: In simple terms, it's a way of making up for damage to nature. Suppose a company wants to build houses on a meadow. If, after doing everything it can to reduce the harm, some loss is unavoidable, it pays to create or restore habitat somewhere else, so that, overall, nature doesn't lose out. Ideally, it ends up better off. Rachel: That sounds almost too good to be true. Gareth: It's not a magic trick. Offsetting is supposed to be the last step in what we call the mitigation hierarchy: first avoid damage, then minimise it, then restore what you can on site, and only then offset what's left.
Rachel: Sian, you're less convinced. Sian: I'm not against the idea in principle. The problem is that, in practice, the last step often becomes the first. Once developers know they can pay to compensate, there's a temptation to skip the harder work of avoiding damage altogether. Critics have called it a licence to trash, and while I wouldn't go that far, I understand the concern. Gareth: To be fair, the rules are designed to stop exactly that. Planners are meant to check that the earlier steps have genuinely been followed.
Rachel: What about the idea of like for like? Can you really swap one piece of nature for another? Sian: For some habitats, perhaps. A new pond can attract dragonflies within a couple of years. But ancient woodland is a different matter entirely. The soil, the fungi, the web of relationships between species: all of that has built up over centuries. You cannot plant a few thousand saplings and call it equivalent. Some things are simply irreplaceable, and no offset can compensate for losing them. Gareth: I completely agree, and the good schemes treat such places as off-limits. Offsetting works best for habitats that can be recreated reasonably quickly.
Rachel: There's also the question of time, isn't there? Sian: Exactly. The meadow is destroyed today, but the new habitat might take twenty or thirty years to mature. In the meantime, the wildlife that depended on it has nowhere to go. And then there's monitoring. Who checks, years later, that the new wetland hasn't dried up or been quietly turned into a car park? Gareth: That's a fair criticism of some early schemes. Increasingly, though, sites have to be legally protected and managed for decades, with regular surveys. I'd rather have a system with flaws that we can fix than no system at all, which is what we had before, when nature was often simply lost without any compensation.
Rachel: In England, many new developments must now leave nature in a measurably better state than before, an approach known as biodiversity net gain. Is that a step forward? Sian: It's a welcome shift in ambition, certainly. Aiming to improve nature rather than merely limit the losses is the right goal. Whether it delivers will depend on how carefully it's measured and enforced. Gareth: And that's where we agree. The principle is sound; the details are everything. Rachel: So, if you each had one message for our listeners? Sian: Treat offsetting as a last resort, not a shortcut. Gareth: And don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. Done well, offsetting can leave nature better off than we found it.