In the 1970s, a young economics professor in Bangladesh made a discovery that would eventually change the way the world thought about poverty. Muhammad Yunus met women in a village near his university who made bamboo furniture but had to borrow money for materials from local lenders at crippling rates of interest. After selling their work, they were left with almost nothing. The sum needed to free a group of them from these debts was strikingly small, and Yunus lent it from his own pocket.
From that small experiment grew the Grameen Bank and, with it, the modern idea of microfinance: providing small loans and other financial services to people who are excluded from ordinary banks. Traditional lenders had long regarded the poor as too risky, because they had no collateral, such as land or property, to offer as security. Yunus's approach relied instead on trust and on small groups of borrowers who supported one another and felt responsible for each other's repayments. Many of the borrowers were women. In 2006, Yunus and the Grameen Bank were jointly awarded the Nobel Peace Prize.
In the decades that followed, microfinance spread across Asia, Africa and Latin America, and its supporters made ambitious claims. Small loans, they argued, would allow people to start businesses, raise their incomes and eventually lift whole communities out of poverty. Stories of women who had bought a sewing machine or a cow and built a thriving enterprise were widely shared, and for a time microfinance was hailed as one of the most promising tools in the fight against poverty.
As the sector grew, however, researchers began to test these claims more rigorously. Several large studies compared similar communities with and without access to small loans. Their results were more sobering than many had hoped. On average, access to credit did help some people to invest in existing businesses and to cope with emergencies, but it rarely transformed household incomes. Few borrowers became entrepreneurs on a large scale; many used loans to smooth out the ups and downs of irregular earnings, or to pay school fees and medical bills.
Other problems emerged too. In some regions, as profit-seeking lenders entered the market, interest rates rose and borrowers took out several loans at once, sometimes from different organisations, in order to repay earlier ones. Critics warned that a tool designed to alleviate poverty could, if poorly regulated, become a new kind of debt trap. Defenders of microfinance responded that these failures reflected bad practice rather than a flaw in the idea itself.
Dr Grace Achieng, a development economist who has studied savings groups in East Africa, believes the debate has matured. 'The early hype did microfinance no favours,' she told me. 'It was never realistic to expect a small loan to solve poverty on its own. But that doesn't make it worthless. For a family living on an unpredictable income, being able to borrow, save or insure against a bad harvest can make the difference between coping and crisis.'
Indeed, the focus has gradually shifted from credit alone to what is often called financial inclusion: access to safe ways of saving, sending money and protecting against risk. In many countries, mobile phone payment services have made such tools available to people who live far from any bank. Microfinance, it now seems, is neither the miracle cure its champions once promised nor the failure its harshest critics describe. Its real value may lie in something less dramatic but no less important: giving people more control over lives that are often uncertain.