Few food technologies have generated as much excitement, or as much suspicion, as meat grown from animal cells. Supporters call it cultivated meat; sceptics prefer 'lab-grown', a label that, they argue, describes it more honestly. To find out where the science really stands, we spoke to Dr Priya Nandakumar, a food scientist in Bristol who has spent much of her career studying how cells can be turned into food.
Interviewer: Let's start with the basics. How is this meat actually made? Dr Nandakumar: In principle, it's surprisingly simple. A small sample of cells is taken from a living animal, usually through a quick biopsy that does the animal little harm. Those cells are placed in a nutrient-rich liquid inside a large steel tank called a bioreactor, where they are kept warm and fed so that they multiply. Given the right conditions, a few cells can become a great many. In practice, of course, each of those steps is fiendishly difficult.
Interviewer: Why is it so difficult? Dr Nandakumar: Partly because cells are fussy. They need sugars, amino acids, vitamins and signalling molecules, and they need them in exactly the right balance. Early experiments relied on a growth liquid made from calf blood, which rather undermined the claim that no animals were involved. Most companies have since developed, or are developing, animal-free alternatives, but these remain expensive. Then there is the question of scale. Growing cells in a laboratory flask is one thing; growing tonnes of them reliably, without contamination, is quite another.
Interviewer: The environmental case is often presented as the main argument in its favour. Is it convincing? Dr Nandakumar: It's promising, but I'd be cautious. Livestock farming uses enormous amounts of land and water and produces a significant share of greenhouse gases, much of it as methane from cattle. Cultivated meat could, in theory, need far less land. However, bioreactors consume a great deal of energy, so the carbon footprint depends heavily on where that energy comes from. Run the factories on fossil fuels, and some studies suggest the benefits could largely disappear. Power them with renewable energy, and the picture looks much better. What matters, in other words, is not just the product but the whole system behind it.
Interviewer: What about taste and texture? Dr Nandakumar: Minced products, such as burgers and nuggets, are the easiest to imitate, because texture matters less. A steak is a different story altogether. It has muscle fibres, fat and connective tissue arranged in a particular structure, and replicating that requires a kind of edible scaffolding for the cells to grow on. We're making progress, but we're not there yet.
Interviewer: Will people actually want to eat it? Dr Nandakumar: That's the million-dollar question. Some consumers find the idea off-putting; they feel that food should come from farms, not factories. Farmers, understandably, worry about their livelihoods. And there are cultural attachments to traditional meat that no amount of technology will simply erase. On the other hand, younger people in particular often say they would be willing to try it. A small number of countries have already approved its sale, though it remains rare and costly.
Interviewer: So is it the future of food? Dr Nandakumar: I'd resist that kind of sweeping prediction. It's far more likely to become one option among many, alongside plant-based foods, more sustainable farming and, quite simply, eating less meat. If it's treated as a silver bullet, people will inevitably be disappointed. If it's seen as one tool among several, it may well earn its place.