Of all the technologies proposed for tackling climate change, few divide opinion as sharply as carbon capture. To its supporters, it is an essential tool for cutting emissions from industries that have no easy alternative. To its critics, it is an expensive distraction that allows polluters to carry on as before. As is often the case, the truth lies somewhere in between.
The basic idea, known as carbon capture and storage, or CCS, is straightforward. Carbon dioxide is separated from the other gases produced by a power station or factory before it reaches the atmosphere. It is then compressed, transported, usually by pipeline or ship, and injected deep underground into rock formations, such as depleted oil and gas fields or porous rocks filled with salty water. There, sealed beneath layers of impermeable rock, it is intended to remain for thousands of years. Nor is the technology entirely new: in Norway, carbon dioxide has been stored beneath the North Sea since the 1990s.
A related but distinct approach is direct air capture, in which machines draw in ordinary air and remove carbon dioxide from it. Because this captures carbon that has already been released, it could in principle help to reverse past pollution rather than merely limit new emissions. The difficulty is that carbon dioxide makes up only a tiny fraction of the air, so extracting it requires large amounts of energy and is, at present, very costly.
Why bother at all, when renewable energy is becoming ever cheaper? The answer lies largely in what engineers call hard-to-abate sectors. Making cement, for example, releases carbon dioxide not only from burning fuel but from the chemical reaction at the heart of the process itself. 'You can power a cement works with wind energy, but you can't change the chemistry,' explains Dr Callum Fraser, an engineer based in Aberdeen. 'For industries like cement, steel and some chemicals, capturing the carbon may be one of very few realistic routes to getting emissions close to zero.' Many scientific assessments of how to limit global warming also assume that some carbon will need to be removed from the atmosphere later this century.
Critics raise several objections. First, the record so far is mixed: a number of projects have captured less carbon than promised, and some have been abandoned because of high costs or technical problems. Second, much of the carbon dioxide captured in the past has been used to push more oil out of ageing oil fields, which hardly helps the climate. Most fundamentally, campaigners fear what is known as a moral hazard: the promise of future capture might give governments and companies an excuse to delay the cheaper and more certain step of cutting emissions now. 'Carbon capture shouldn't be a licence to keep burning fossil fuels,' argues Megan Holloway, who works for an environmental charity in Cardiff. 'The first priority must always be not to produce the carbon in the first place.'
There are practical questions, too. Storage sites must be carefully chosen and monitored to make sure the gas does not leak, and a vast network of pipelines and wells would be needed to make a real difference. Public acceptance cannot be taken for granted either; few communities are enthusiastic about new industrial sites on their doorstep.
Interestingly, Dr Fraser and Ms Holloway agree on more than one might expect. Both accept that carbon capture is no substitute for renewable energy, greater efficiency and cutting waste. Both also accept that, for a limited number of industries, it may prove necessary. Where they differ is in emphasis: one sees a tool that must be developed urgently, the other a tool that must be kept firmly in its place. Perhaps the most sensible conclusion is that carbon capture should be judged not by the promises made about it, but by what it actually delivers, and that it should be used to complement emission cuts, never to replace them.