Every Thursday, the debating club at Hillside Sixth Form College in Bristol argues about a topic in the news. This week's question was: 'Should governments tax sugary food and drink?' Here is part of the debate, chaired by the club's teacher, Mr Patel.
Mr Patel: Let's start with some background. Grace, could you explain what a sugar tax is? Grace: Of course. It's a tax on products with a lot of added sugar – usually soft drinks. In the UK, a levy on sugary soft drinks was introduced in 2018. The companies that make the drinks pay it, and drinks with more sugar are charged more. Pure fruit juice and milk drinks aren't included. Mr Patel: And you're in favour? Grace: Definitely. Too much sugar is linked to tooth decay and weight gain, and fizzy drinks are a big source of sugar in many teenagers' diets. What I find most convincing is that lots of companies reformulated their drinks – they cut the sugar – so that they would pay less. People got healthier drinks without having to change their habits at all.
Mr Patel: Owen, you're arguing against. Owen: Yes. I agree that eating less sugar is a good idea – nobody's arguing with that. My main concern is fairness. Families on low incomes spend a bigger share of their money on food and drink, so if prices go up, they're the ones who feel the pinch most. Grace: But the government said the money raised would help pay for school sport, so some of it comes back to young people. Owen: That's a fair point. Even so, I think it's a bit of a nanny state approach. Adults should be trusted to make their own choices. I'd rather see better food education in schools, so that people understand what they're eating.
Mr Patel: Is one type of drink really the problem, though? Sugar is in cakes, sweets, breakfast cereals… Owen: Exactly. A drinks tax on its own can't solve a complicated problem. People might simply switch to other sugary snacks. Grace: I don't think anyone claims it's a silver bullet. It's one tool among many. You can have education and a tax – they're not mutually exclusive. Owen: OK, I'll give you that.
At the end, the club voted. The result was close: a small majority supported Grace's side, but several students said Owen had changed their minds about fairness. As Mr Patel pointed out, that is exactly what a good debate should do – not just pick a winner, but help everyone see the question more clearly.