'Money can't buy happiness' is one of those sayings that we hear so often that we rarely stop to question it. Yet if you ask a family struggling to pay the rent whether a little more money would make life better, the answer is likely to be a firm yes. So who is right? As with most big questions, I think the truth lies somewhere in the middle.
Let's begin with what the research broadly agrees on. For people who don't have enough to cover the essentials – food, heating, a safe place to live – extra money makes an enormous difference. It reduces daily worry, improves health and gives people more choices. In this sense, money doesn't so much buy happiness as remove a great deal of unhappiness.
The picture becomes more complicated further up the income scale. For many years, a famous idea suggested that once people earned a comfortable salary, more money stopped making them any happier. More recent studies have challenged this, finding that wellbeing may keep rising with income for many people, although each extra pound tends to matter less than the one before. Economists are still debating the details, which is a useful reminder that research doesn't always give us neat answers.
What seems clearer is that the way we spend money matters as much as how much we have. Psychologists have found that people often get more lasting pleasure from experiences – a trip to the seaside, a concert, a meal with friends – than from possessions. A new phone is exciting for a few weeks, but then we simply get used to it. This is sometimes called the hedonic treadmill: we keep running towards the next purchase, but our happiness stays in roughly the same place.
Spending on other people also seems to pay off. In several experiments, volunteers who were given a small sum to spend on someone else reported feeling happier than those who spent it on themselves. Generosity, it appears, is good for the giver as well as the receiver.
There is another side to the argument, of course. Chasing money can backfire if it means working such long hours that we have no time for family, friends or rest. Comparing ourselves with wealthier neighbours – or with the glamorous lives we see online – can leave us feeling poorer than we really are.
So, can money buy happiness? Not directly, and not without limits. But it can buy security, time and the chance to share good moments with others. Perhaps the wiser question is not 'How much do I have?' but 'What am I using it for?'