Every summer, teenagers across the UK sit in silent exam halls, writing as fast as they can for two or three hours. For many of them, those few hours will decide which course they take next. But is a final exam really the fairest way to measure what a student has learnt? Or would coursework, completed over several months, give a truer picture? We asked two teachers from Hartley Academy in Norwich to make their case.
Mr Daniel Okafor, who teaches history, is firmly on the side of exams. "Exams are a level playing field," he says. "Everyone answers the same questions, in the same room, under the same conditions. Nobody can get help from a parent or copy something from the internet." He also believes that preparing for exams teaches valuable skills. "Revising forces you to review a whole year's learning and see how the pieces fit together. And learning to stay calm under pressure is something you'll need in adult life, whether it's a job interview or a driving test."
Ms Rachel Lin, an English and drama teacher, sees things differently. "Some of my most talented students simply freeze in exams," she explains. "They know the material inside out, but anxiety stops them from showing it. One bad morning, a headache or a sleepless night, can undo two years of hard work." Coursework, she argues, rewards steady effort. "Students can research a topic in depth, draft their work, get feedback and improve it. That's how real writers, scientists and engineers work. Nobody in the real world has to write an essay from memory in forty-five minutes."
Mr Okafor accepts that exam stress is real, but he has concerns about coursework too. "It's very hard to be sure that the work is entirely the student's own," he points out. "Some families can afford tutors or have more time to help at home, so coursework can actually make inequality worse." Ms Lin admits that this is a fair point, but she believes schools can deal with it. "Much of the work can be done in class, under a teacher's supervision. And we get to know our students' writing, so we usually notice when something doesn't sound like them."
Interestingly, the two teachers agree more than you might expect. Both think that a combination of the two methods is probably the best solution. Exams could test knowledge and the ability to think quickly, while coursework could assess skills such as research, creativity and independent thinking. "The question isn't really exams or coursework," says Ms Lin. "It's how we balance them." Mr Okafor nods. "And whatever system we choose, students need to be taught how to cope with it."
So, which side are you on? Write to the school magazine and let us know.