C2 British · Text 15
A Voicemail from an Editor
Editor Clare Henshaw leaves a long, tactful voicemail for a first-time novelist about what works in his book, what doesn't, a new deadline and a meeting near King's Cross.
47 sentences · Tap a sentence to hear it again
Text
Hi, Tom, it's Clare Henshaw from Larkspur Books. It's just after nine on Monday morning. I did try you on Friday, but I think I caught you on the way somewhere. Nothing's wrong, I promise. I've finished the manuscript of The Glass Orchard and I've got quite a lot to say, so I'm going to say most of it now and we can talk properly later in the week. I'm aware this might turn into a small audiobook, so do make yourself a cup of tea.
First things first. I've read it twice now, the second time on the train back from Edinburgh, and the opening is genuinely wonderful. That first chapter, with Nell walking through the orchard before dawn and finding the glass jars hanging in the apple trees, is one of the most confident openings I've read from a first-time writer in years. I actually missed my stop. So please don't touch it, or at least not without ringing me first.
Now, the harder part, and I want to put this carefully, because I think the problem is much smaller than it'll sound. Chapters four to seven slow the story right down. Nell goes to London, she sorts out the flat, there's the job interview, there's the long dinner with her cousin, and it's all beautifully written, line by line, but nothing really changes for her. By the end of chapter seven I'd almost forgotten about the orchard, and I don't think that's what you want the reader to feel. My honest advice would be to condense those four chapters into two. At the moment the book's around a hundred and four thousand words. If you came down to somewhere nearer ninety-two thousand, I don't think anybody would miss a single scene.
The other thing is the flashback. You know the one, where Ada remembers the great storm of 1987 and watching half the trees come down in a single night. At the moment it comes in chapter eleven, and it's the most moving thing in the whole book. But by then the reader has been wondering for two hundred pages why Ada refuses to talk about the orchard. What if we moved it much earlier, to the end of chapter three? I think the reader would understand her straight away, and every scene between her and Nell after that would carry so much more weight. It's only a suggestion, and you may well have a good reason for keeping it where it is, in which case I'd love to hear it.
On timing. I know we originally said the end of February for the revised draft, and given what I'm asking for, I don't think that's fair on you. I've spoken to Priya in production, and we can push it back to the fourteenth of March without upsetting the schedule for the autumn. So the fourteenth of March is your new deadline. Please don't feel you have to rush to beat it.
And I'd really like to talk all of this through in person rather than in a long, intimidating email full of page numbers. Could you come into the office on Thursday at half past two? We're five minutes' walk from King's Cross, the building with the green door opposite the bookshop. Just ask at reception and they'll send you up to the fourth floor. If Thursday's no good, I could also do Friday at ten. The design team have done some very early sketches for the cover, and I'd love to show you those while you're here. They're rough, but there's one in particular I think you'll like.
Could you let me know by Wednesday which of those works? A text is absolutely fine, or an email if you'd rather.
Last thing, and then I really will let you go. I know getting notes on your first novel can feel a bit bruising, even when they're kindly meant. So I just want to say clearly that everyone here who's read it loves it. We wouldn't be asking for changes if we didn't think it was worth getting exactly right. This is a very good book, Tom, and I think with a few months' work it'll be an exceptional one. Right, that's more than enough from me. Speak soon. Bye.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| condense/kənˈdens/ | make a piece of writing shorter while keeping the important parts |
| flashback/ˈflæʃbæk/ | a part of a story that goes back to events that happened earlier |
| deadline/ˈdedlaɪn/ | the time or date by which something must be finished |
| intimidating/ɪnˈtɪmɪdeɪtɪŋ/ | making you feel nervous or less confident |
| reception/rɪˈsepʃn/ | the desk near the entrance of a building where visitors go first |
| bruising/ˈbruːzɪŋ/ | hurting your feelings or confidence |
| exceptional/ɪkˈsepʃənl/ | much better than usual |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.