C2 British · Text 16
The Beaver Question
At an evening talk in Devon, ecologist Dr Owen Price weighs up the benefits of bringing beavers back to rivers against the real worries of farmers.
40 sentences · Tap a sentence to hear it again
Text
Good evening, and thank you for coming out on such a wet night, which, as it happens, is rather fitting, because tonight I want to talk about water, and about an animal that has very strong opinions on where water should go. I'm talking, of course, about the beaver. Beavers were hunted to extinction in Britain roughly four hundred years ago, mostly for their fur. For centuries our rivers have flowed without them, and most of us have never known anything different. So when wild beavers turned up on the River Otter in East Devon, nobody was quite sure where they'd come from, and there was a lively argument about what to do with them.
In the end, rather than removing them, the authorities agreed to a trial. The River Otter Beaver Trial began in 2015 and ran for five years. Its aim was simple to state and much harder to carry out: to find out what beavers actually do to a river, and to the people who live along it, rather than what we imagine they do. By the end of the trial, the original handful of animals had grown to around fifteen family groups.
Beavers are, in effect, engineers. They build dams of branches, mud and stones to create deep, still pools where they can feel safe from predators. What surprised many people is what those dams do during a storm. Instead of rushing straight downstream, rainwater is held back in a series of ponds and released slowly, over hours rather than minutes. At one site we monitored, the peak flow during heavy rain, that's the highest point the water reaches, was reduced by around a third downstream of the dams. For a village that floods regularly, a third is not a small number. The ponds also trap soil and sediment that would otherwise wash into the river, so the water below them is noticeably cleaner.
There are other benefits too. The pools and the dead wood around them provide homes for insects, frogs, birds and bats, and in dry summers they act as a kind of reservoir, keeping water in the landscape when the rest of the river is running low. Ecologists describe beavers as a keystone species, meaning that their presence changes the whole ecosystem around them.
Now, I promised the organisers a balanced talk, and I meant it. It would be dishonest to stand here and tell you that beavers are a pure blessing. I've spent a lot of time in farmhouse kitchens over the past few years, and I've heard some very genuine worries. One farmer near Ottery St Mary lost the use of almost two hectares of grazing land for a whole season when a dam raised the water level in a ditch. Others have had valuable trees felled, or found that beavers had burrowed into riverbanks and weakened them. For a family business working on narrow margins, that isn't an abstract ecological debate. It's lost income, and sometimes a great deal of stress.
So what can be done? The trial tested a range of practical measures. Where a dam threatens fields or a road, it can be lowered, or fitted with a pipe, known rather wonderfully as a beaver deceiver, which is one of my favourite technical terms, that keeps the water at a safe level without the beavers noticing. Valuable trees can be protected with wire mesh or a special gritty paint that beavers dislike. And in a small number of cases, animals can be moved elsewhere. In 2020, the government decided that the Otter beavers could stay for good.
But the hardest question, in my view, isn't scientific at all. It's about who pays. If beavers reduce flooding in a town ten miles downstream, but the cost falls on one farmer upstream, then fairness demands that the farmer should be compensated, and that somebody is on hand to help quickly when problems arise.
So where does that leave us? My own conclusion, and you're very welcome to disagree, is that beavers can be valuable partners in managing our rivers, but only if we treat the people who live alongside them as partners too. Bringing an animal back after four centuries isn't just an ecological project; it's a social one. Right, I've talked for long enough. I can see at least three hands up already, so let's start with the gentleman at the back.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| extinction/ɪkˈstɪŋkʃn/ | the end of a kind of animal or plant, when none of them are left alive |
| dams/dæmz/ | walls built across a river or stream to hold the water back |
| sediment/ˈsedɪmənt/ | sand, mud and small stones carried by water that settle at the bottom |
| keystone species/ˈkiːstəʊn ˈspiːʃiːz/ | an animal or plant that many other living things in its area depend on |
| ecosystem/ˈiːkəʊsɪstəm/ | all the plants, animals and other living things in an area and the way they affect each other |
| felled/feld/ | cut down (used about trees) |
| burrowed/ˈbʌrəʊd/ | dug a hole or tunnel in the ground to live in |
| margins/ˈmɑːdʒɪnz/ | the difference between what a business earns and what it spends; narrow ones mean very little profit |
| compensated/ˈkɒmpənseɪtɪd/ | paid money because of a loss or damage that was not your fault |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.