C2 British · Dialogue 6
The Pollinator Survey
Two ecologists disagree about why bee numbers have fallen at their survey sites and decide what their report can honestly claim.
23 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Dr Anna Kerr:Right, David, before we send anything to the trust, I want us to agree on what these numbers actually show. Across the twelve survey sites, bumblebee counts are down twenty-two per cent on last summer.
Dr David Mensah:Twenty-two per cent overall, yes. But it isn't evenly spread, and that's what's been nagging at me all week.
Dr Anna Kerr:Go on.
Dr David Mensah:Seven of the sites are down by roughly a third. The other five have barely moved. If it were simply the weather, I'd expect the decline to be more or less the same everywhere.
Dr Anna Kerr:Not necessarily. June was the wettest on record for this part of Wiltshire. We lost eleven survey days out of thirty. Bees don't forage in heavy rain, so fewer bees on the transects is exactly what you'd predict. I'm not convinced we need to look much further than that.
Dr David Mensah:Except that the rain didn't fall on random sites. It fell on all twelve. So why would five of them be unaffected?
Dr Anna Kerr:Microclimate, possibly. The five stable sites are mostly on south-facing slopes. They'd dry out faster after a downpour.
Dr David Mensah:Two of them are. The other three are down in the valley, and they're about as damp as anywhere on the estate. What the seven declining sites do have in common is that the farm changed its hedge-cutting contractor last autumn. I checked with the estate manager on Tuesday. The new firm flails the hedges every year in September, rather than every other year in late winter.
Dr Anna Kerr:And that matters because…?
Dr David Mensah:Because if you cut blackthorn and hawthorn hard every autumn, you remove the wood that would have flowered the following spring. No spring blossom means no early food for queens coming out of hibernation. Fewer queens means fewer colonies, and fewer workers by June.
Dr Anna Kerr:It's a plausible mechanism, I'll grant you that. But it's a story, David. We've got one season of data, and the hedge cutting is confounded with the weather. We can't untangle the two from what we've got.
Dr David Mensah:I'm not suggesting we put it in the abstract as a finding. I'm saying that if we blame the whole drop on the rain, we're making exactly the same leap in the opposite direction.
Dr Anna Kerr:Fair point. That would be overstating it too. So what can we honestly claim?
Dr David Mensah:That counts fell by twenty-two per cent, that the fall coincided with an exceptionally wet June, and that it was concentrated at the sites where hedge management changed. Three statements, all true, and none of them a conclusion about cause.
Dr Anna Kerr:I could live with that. Though the trust will want to know which explanation is right. They're deciding whether to fund the hedge project for another three years.
Dr David Mensah:Then we tell them what would settle it. We ask the contractor to leave alternate hedges uncut next autumn on, say, four of the seven sites. If the bees recover where the hedges were left and not elsewhere, that's a far stronger case than anything we can make now.
Dr Anna Kerr:And I'd want the blossom data. The volunteers recorded flowering in April, didn't they?
Dr David Mensah:On paper forms, which are sitting in a box in the barn. Nobody's typed them up yet.
Dr Anna Kerr:Well, that's our Monday sorted, then. If the seven sites had noticeably less blossom in April, your theory gets a lot more interesting. If they didn't, I'll expect you to buy the coffee for a month.
Dr David Mensah:Deal. And if they did?
Dr Anna Kerr:Then I'll admit, in writing, that the rain wasn't the whole story.
Dr David Mensah:I'll hold you to that. Shall we draft the report on Wednesday?
Dr Anna Kerr:Wednesday it is. And we send it by the twenty-ninth, whatever the blossom says.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| nagging/ˈnæɡɪŋ/ | worrying someone again and again, so they cannot forget it |
| forage/ˈfɒrɪdʒ/ | to go around looking for food |
| transects/ˈtrænsekts/ | fixed lines across an area along which scientists count plants or animals |
| downpour/ˈdaʊnpɔː/ | a sudden fall of very heavy rain |
| flails/fleɪlz/ | cuts plants roughly with a machine that has fast-turning blades or chains |
| hibernation/ˌhaɪbəˈneɪʃn/ | the long sleep some animals have through the winter |
| plausible/ˈplɔːzəbl/ | seeming reasonable and possibly true |
| confounded/kənˈfaʊndɪd/ | mixed up with another cause, so the effects of each cannot be separated |
| overstating/ˌəʊvəˈsteɪtɪŋ/ | saying something is bigger, stronger or surer than it really is |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.