C2 British · Dialogue 21
Interview on the Ice
A radio journalist asks a glaciologist in Svalbard for a simple headline about a shrinking glacier, and she explains why the truth needs more care.
22 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Mark Bennett:Dr Ellison, can you hear me? The line keeps dropping in and out.
Dr Kate Ellison:I can hear you, Mark, just about. There's a slight delay, so forgive me if I talk over you. I'm standing outside the hut, and the wind's picked up in the last hour.
Mark Bennett:Then let's get straight to it. Your team has been measuring the glacier behind the station since 2004. For listeners who've never seen it, what's actually happening to it?
Dr Kate Ellison:In plain terms, it's getting thinner and shorter. Where I'm standing, the ice surface is roughly forty metres lower than it was in 1990. To put that in perspective, that's about the height of a twelve-storey building, gone in a little over three decades.
Mark Bennett:Forty metres. So can we say, as our headline, that the glacier will have vanished by 2050?
Dr Kate Ellison:I'd rather you didn't, to be honest. It's a tempting line, but it isn't what the data say. We don't have a single date; we have a range, and it depends heavily on how warm the summers turn out to be.
Mark Bennett:But surely the listener just wants to know: is it disappearing or isn't it?
Dr Kate Ellison:It's shrinking, unmistakably. That part isn't in doubt. What's uncertain is the pace. In some years we lose a metre and a half of thickness; in a cold, snowy year, barely thirty centimetres. If you draw a straight line through a few bad summers, you get a very dramatic date. If you include the milder ones, the date moves back by decades.
Mark Bennett:Isn't that rather a convenient way of avoiding the question?
Dr Kate Ellison:Ha! I can see why it might sound like that. But overstating it does real damage. If we announce a date and the glacier's still there, people conclude that scientists were crying wolf, and then they stop listening altogether.
Mark Bennett:Fair enough. So how do you measure something like this? I imagine you're not out there with a tape measure.
Dr Kate Ellison:Not quite, although we do use some surprisingly low-tech kit. We've drilled a line of thirty-two metal stakes into the ice, and every spring and autumn we measure how much of each one is showing. We combine that with GPS surveys and images from satellites and drones.
Mark Bennett:And how reliable are they? Couldn't a stake simply lean over in a storm?
Dr Kate Ellison:They do, occasionally, and two have disappeared completely, which is why we never rely on a single one. Each measurement has an error of a few centimetres, but across thirty-two stakes and more than twenty years, the overall trend is extremely robust.
Mark Bennett:All right, let me try again. If you were writing the headline, what would it be?
Dr Kate Ellison:Something like: Arctic glacier has lost a third of its thickness in a generation, and the loss is speeding up. That's accurate, it's striking, and I can defend every word of it.
Mark Bennett:A third. That's actually more alarming than the date.
Dr Kate Ellison:I think so too. Numbers we've measured tend to persuade people more than predictions do. And the speeding up matters: the rate since 2010 is nearly double what it was in the nineties.
Mark Bennett:Final question, and a personal one. You've spent sixteen summers on that ice. How does it feel to watch it go?
Dr Kate Ellison:Honestly? It's a strange kind of grief. There's a ridge I used to climb in my first season to eat my lunch, and it simply isn't there any more. But the work keeps me going. If we can describe the change precisely, people can make decisions based on facts rather than fear.
Mark Bennett:Dr Kate Ellison, thank you, and I hope the wind dies down for you.
Dr Kate Ellison:Thanks, Mark. It's forecast to get worse, actually, so I'd better go and check on the stakes.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| put that in perspective/ˌpʊt ðæt ɪn pəˈspektɪv/ | to compare a fact with something familiar so people understand how big or important it is |
| unmistakably/ˌʌnmɪˈsteɪkəbli/ | in a way that is completely clear and cannot be doubted |
| pace/peɪs/ | the speed at which something happens |
| crying wolf/ˌkraɪɪŋ ˈwʊlf/ | warning people about a danger that does not come, so they stop believing you |
| stakes/steɪks/ | long thin poles pushed into the ground or ice |
| robust/rəʊˈbʌst/ | strong and reliable; not easily shown to be wrong |
| striking/ˈstraɪkɪŋ/ | very noticeable and interesting |
| grief/ɡriːf/ | deep sadness, usually when something or someone is lost |
| ridge/rɪdʒ/ | a long narrow raised part of land or ice |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.